Grand Jury Testimony

of Detective Jeff Leslie, Part 2

167

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

              MR. HUM, YOU WISH TO RECALL --

24

       MR. HUM:  RECALL DETECTIVE JEFF LESLIE.

25

26

              (PAUSE IN THE PROCEEDINGS.)

27

              (THE WITNESS ENTERED THE GRAND JURY

28

              HEARING ROOM.)

168

1

       MS. PRIVER:  HAVE A SEAT.

2

              YOU WERE PREVIOUSLY SWORN AND YOU ARE STILL

3

UNDER OATH.  DO YOU UNDERSTAND THAT?

4

       THE WITNESS:  YES, MA'AM.

5

       MS. PRIVER:  STATE YOUR NAME FOR THE RECORD.

6

       THE WITNESS:  JEFFREY LESLIE.  L-E-S-L-I-E.

7

       MS. PRIVER:  THANK YOU.

8

              MR. HUM.

9

       MR. HUM:  THANK YOU.

10

11

                     JEFFREY LESLIE,

12

RECALLED AS A WITNESS BEFORE THE GRAND JURY OF THE COUNTY

13

OF LOS ANGELES, HAVING BEEN PREVIOUSLY SWORN, RESUMED THE

14

STAND AND TESTIFIED FURTHER AS FOLLOWS:

15

16

                 EXAMINATION (CONTINUED)

17

BY MR. HUM:

18

       Q      GOOD MORNING, DETECTIVE LESLIE.

19

       A      GOOD MORNING.

20

       Q      DETECTIVE LESLIE, YESTERDAY YOU TOLD US YOU

21

HAD CONTACT WITH CAMERON BROWN DOWN AT THE ARCHERY RANGE

22

AND THEN YOU REQUESTED THAT HE GO BACK TO LOMITA STATION

23

TO WAIT TO BE INTERVIEWED; IS THAT CORRECT?

24

       A      YES, THAT'S CORRECT.

25

       Q      AND AT SOME POINT AFTER YOU HAD DONE SOME

26

INVESTIGATION AT THE ACTUAL SCENE, DID YOU, IN FACT, GO

27

BACK TO LOMITA STATION TO SPEAK WITH MR. BROWN?

28

       A      YEAH.  WE MET WITH HIM JUST AFTER MIDNIGHT

169

1

AT LOMITA STATION.

2

       Q      AND WHEN YOU SAY "WE," WHO WAS THAT?

3

       A      MYSELF AND MY PARTNER, DETECTIVE DANNY

4

SMITH.

5

       Q      AND DO YOU RECALL ABOUT WHAT TIME IT WAS

6

THAT YOU FIRST CONTACTED MR. BROWN AT LOMITA STATION?

7

       A      TWENTY AFTER MIDNIGHT, 25 MINUTES AFTER

8

MIDNIGHT.

9

       Q      SO THAT WOULD HAVE BEEN THE EARLY MORNING

10

HOURS OF NOVEMBER 9TH OF 2000?

11

       A      YES, THAT'S CORRECT.

12

       Q      NOW, DETECTIVE LESLIE, CAN YOU DESCRIBE FOR

13

US THE CLOTHING THAT MR. BROWN WAS WEARING AT LOMITA

14

STATION?

15

              FIRST, WAS IT THE SAME CLOTHING THAT YOU

16

HAD SEEN HIM WEARING AT THE ARCHERY RANGE?

17

       A      YES, IT WAS THE SAME CLOTHING.

18

       Q      CAN YOU DESCRIBE IT FOR US?

19

       A      HE WAS WEARING A LIGHT-COLORED, OFF-WHITE,

20

YELLOWISH T-SHIRT; SOME, WHAT I WOULD DESCRIBE AS,

21

WALKING SHORTS; WHITE SOCKS AND HIKING BOOTS.

22

       Q      AND DID YOU HAVE MR. BROWN'S CLOTHING

23

PHOTOGRAPHED WHILE HE WAS STILL WEARING IT?

24

       A      YES, WE DID.

25

       Q      SHOWING YOU WHAT'S BEEN MARKED AS

26

EXHIBIT 15, ARE THESE PHOTOGRAPHS THAT YOU HAD TAKEN OF

27

MR. BROWN'S CLOTHING AT LOMITA STATION?

28

       A      YES, THEY ARE.

170

1

       Q      IF YOU COULD JUST STEP DOWN HERE AND

2

DESCRIBE FOR US ANYTHING THAT YOU NOTED THAT SEEMED

3

UNUSUAL ABOUT MR. BROWN'S CLOTHING.

4

       A      PHOTOGRAPH A IS CAMERON BROWN.  IT'S A

5

FULL-FIGURE PHOTOGRAPH JUST DEPICTING THE GENERAL

6

CLOTHING.

7

              PHOTOGRAPH B, AT THE TOP LEFT SHOULDER AREA

8

ON THE FRONT OF HIS SHIRT WAS A SMALL BLOOD DROPLET AND

9

SMEAR THAT WAS NOTED ON THE FRONT OF HIS T-SHIRT.

10

              MOVING TO PHOTOGRAPH C, THERE IS, ON THE

11

BACK LEFT-HAND PORTION OF HIS T-SHIRT, BLOOD SOAKAGE,

12

ALONG WITH SOME COAGULATED BLOOD THAT HAD MATTED AGAINST

13

THE COTTON T-SHIRT, AS WELL AS ADDITIONAL BLOOD SMEARS IN

14

THE CENTER AND BLOOD DROPLETS AND SMEARS TOWARDS THE

15

LOWER PORTION OF HIS BACK.

16

              PHOTOGRAPH D, ONCE AGAIN, IS JUST A CLOSER

17

PHOTOGRAPH OF THE SAME BLOODSTAINS AND BLOOD PATTERNS AND

18

SMEARS AND DROPLETS.

19

              PHOTOGRAPH E SHOWS THE BOOTS, HIKING BOOTS,

20

IF YOU WILL, THAT HE WAS WEARING THE NIGHT THAT WE HAD

21

CONTACTED HIM.  WE NOTED THAT THEY WERE WET AND HAD SOME

22

SAND RESIDUE ALONG THE TOP AND ALSO THE PORTION WHERE THE

23

SOLE IS ATTACHED TO THE UPPER PORTION OF THE SHOE.

24

              PHOTOGRAPH F IS A SHOT OF THE BACK PORTION

25

OF HIS LEGS AND FEET.  YOU CAN SEE IN THE PHOTOGRAPH ON

26

BOTH THE LEFT AND RIGHT LEGS ON THE REAR, JUST AT AND

27

BELOW THE CALF AREA, IS SOME BLOOD SMEARS AND SOAKAGE

28

ALONG THE TOP PORTION OF HIS WHITE SOCKS.

171

1

       Q      THANK YOU.

2

              NOW, DETECTIVE LESLIE, EXCEPT FOR THE BLOOD

3

ON MR. BROWN'S CLOTHING AND EXCEPT FOR HIS SOCKS AND HIS

4

HIKING BOOTS, WAS THE REST OF HIS CLOTHING DRY?

5

       A      THE REMAINDER OF HIS CLOTHING, YES,

6

APPEARED TO BE DRY.

7

       Q      NOW, DID YOU SPEAK WITH MR. BROWN AT LOMITA

8

STATION ABOUT WHAT HAD HAPPENED?

9

       A      YES, I DID.

10

       Q      DID YOU ALSO GET SOME BACKGROUND

11

INFORMATION FROM HIM?

12

       A      YES, WE DID.

13

       Q      DID MR. BROWN TELL YOU HOW OLD HE WAS?

14

       A      YES.

15

       Q      HOW OLD WAS HE?

16

       A      THIRTY-NINE YEARS OLD.

17

       Q      DID YOU NOTE HOW MUCH MR. BROWN WEIGHED AND

18

HOW TALL HE WAS?

19

       A      YES.

20

       Q      AND HOW TALL WAS HE?

21

       A      HE WAS APPROXIMATELY SIX-TWO, SIX-THREE,

22

WEIGHED APPROXIMATELY 220, 230 POUNDS.

23

       Q      DID YOU ASK MR. BROWN WHAT HIS OCCUPATION

24

WAS?

25

       A      YES, I DID.

26

       Q      AND WHAT DID HE TELL YOU HIS OCCUPATION

27

WAS?

28

       A      HE WAS A BAGGAGE HANDLER FOR AMERICAN

172

1

AIRLINES, WHICH BASICALLY ENTAILED LOADING AND UNLOADING

2

SUITCASES, BAGS, FROM THE UNDERCARRIAGE OR UNDERBELLY OF

3

AIRCRAFT ONTO A TRANSPORT AND BACK AND FORTH.

4

       Q      NOW, DID YOU ALSO ASK MR. BROWN WHAT HAD

5

HAPPENED THAT LED TO THE DEATH OF LAUREN?

6

       A      YES, I DID.

7

       Q      AND WHAT DID HE TELL YOU HAPPENED?

8

       A      HE RELAYED TO US THAT HE HAD A

9

NON-SUPERVISED VISIT GRANTED AND IT WAS HIS DAY TO VISIT

10

WITH LAUREN KEY, WHO WAS HIS BIOLOGICAL DAUGHTER.  HE

11

TOLD US THAT AT 12:30 THAT AFTERNOON HE PICKED HER UP

12

FROM THE CHRISTIAN MONTESSORI SCHOOL.

13

       Q      LET ME ASK YOU THIS:  DID HE TELL YOU

14

WHETHER OR NOT HE HAD WORKED THAT DAY PRIOR TO PICKING UP

15

LAUREN?

16

       A      NO, THAT WAS HIS DAY OFF.  HIS VISITATIONS

17

WERE SCHEDULED FOR HIS DAYS OFF.

18

       Q      AND DID HE TELL YOU ANYTHING ABOUT HIS

19

RELATIONSHIP WITH LAUREN'S MOTHER, SARAH?

20

       A      BRIEFLY, YES.

21

       Q      WHAT DID HE TELL YOU ABOUT THAT?

22

       A      HE TOLD US THAT THEY DID NOT GET ALONG VERY

23

WELL AND ELABORATED TO AN EXTENT THAT, I BELIEVE THE

24

QUOTATION WAS, THEY HARDLY SPOKE.

25

       Q      LET'S GO BACK, THEN, TO WHAT HE WAS TELLING

26

YOU ABOUT WHAT HAD OCCURRED THAT DAY.  YOU SAID THAT HE

27

TOLD YOU HE PICKED HER UP AT THE MONTESSORI SCHOOL?

28

       A      HE PICKED HER UP AT 12:30 IN THE AFTERNOON

173

1

AT THE CHRISTIAN MONTESSORI SCHOOL WHICH LAUREN ATTENDED,

2

WHICH IS IN THE CITY OF COSTA MESA.

3

       Q      AND DID HE TELL YOU WHAT TIME HE WAS

4

SUPPOSED TO BRING HER BACK TO HER MOTHER'S HOUSE?

5

       A      HE WAS SUPPOSED TO RETURN HER, HIS

6

VISITATION WAS OVER, AT 7:00 P.M.

7

       Q      DID HE TELL YOU WHAT LAUREN'S EMOTIONAL

8

STATE WAS WHEN HE WENT TO PICK HER UP?

9

       A      YES.

10

       Q      WHAT DID HE TELL YOU ABOUT THAT?

11

       A      HE SAID THAT LAUREN INDICATED TO HIM THAT

12

SHE HAD BEEN SICK; IT WAS EVIDENT THAT SHE WAS UPSET AND

13

APPEARED AS IF SHE WAS CRYING, AND SHE HAD ALSO TOLD HIM

14

THAT SHE WAS NOT SUPPOSED TO GO WITH HIM THAT DAY.

15

       Q      AND WHAT DID HE SAY HAPPENED THEN?

16

       A      HE INFORMED BOTH THE CHILD AND THE SCHOOL

17

ADMINISTRATORS THAT NO, SHE WAS SUPPOSED TO GO WITH HIM

18

THAT DAY, IT WAS HIS GRANTED VISITATION DAY, AND TOLD THE

19

ADMINISTRATOR, WHO HE WAS CHECKING THE CHILD OUT WITH,

20

THAT HER MOTHER, REFERRING TO LAUREN'S MOTHER, TELLS

21

LAUREN TO SAY THOSE TYPES OF THINGS.

22

       Q      DID HE RELATE TO YOU WHETHER OR NOT LAUREN

23

WAS CRYING AT THE TIME?

24

       A      YES.

25

       Q      WAS SHE?

26

       A      YES, SHE WAS CRYING.

27

       Q      DID MR. BROWN TELL YOU THAT EVENTUALLY

28

LAUREN DID GO WITH HIM?

174

1

       A      YES, HE DID.

2

       Q      AND DID MR. BROWN TELL YOU WHERE HE HAD

3

ORIGINALLY ANTICIPATED GOING AFTER HE PICKED UP LAUREN?

4

       A      HIS ORIGINAL INTENTIONS FROM WHAT HE TOLD

5

US WERE TO DRIVE THE CHILD, LAUREN, TO HIS RESIDENCE AS

6

HIS WIFE, MISS BROWN, OR MRS. BROWN, WAS EXPECTING THEM

7

AT THEIR APARTMENT WHERE THEY RESIDED.

8

       Q      SO ACCORDING TO HIM THE ORIGINAL PLAN WAS

9

TO JUST TAKE HER BACK HOME?

10

       A      TO TAKE THE CHILD HOME, YES.

11

       Q      OKAY.  AND WHAT DID HE SAY HE DECIDED TO DO

12

INSTEAD?

13

       A      HE TOLD US THAT BECAUSE LAUREN WAS UPSET HE

14

DECIDED TO SPEND SOME TIME, JUST THE TWO OF THEM ALONE,

15

AND NOT TAKE HER BACK TO THE HOME.

16

       Q      DID HE INDICATE TO YOU THAT THERE WAS ANY

17

REASON WHY LAUREN WOULD BE LESS UPSET JUST SPENDING TIME

18

WITH HIM THAN WITH HIM AND HIS WIFE?

19

       A      NO, THERE WAS NO EXPLANATION OFFERED AS TO

20

WHY.

21

       Q      SO WHAT DID MR. BROWN SAY HE DID THEN?

22

       A      HE TOLD US THAT HE THEN DROVE TO ABALONE

23

COVE.  HE BACKED UP A LITTLE BIT IN THE INTERVIEW AND

24

SAID THAT HE HAD TRIED TO MAKE SEVERAL CALLS ALONG THE

25

WAY OR ALONG THE DRIVE TO NOTIFY HIS WIFE, MRS. BROWN,

26

THAT THEY WOULD NOT BE COMING, THAT LAUREN WAS UPSET;

27

HOWEVER, THE LINE WAS BUSY.  THEY CONTINUED ON AND THEY

28

ARRIVED AT THE ABALONE COVE SHORELINE PARK, WHERE THEY

175

1

STOPPED AND HE ULTIMATELY WAS ABLE TO GET AHOLD OF HIS

2

WIFE AND INFORM HER THAT THEY WOULD JUST BE SPENDING SOME

3

TIME TOGETHER.

4

       Q      THAT'S WHAT HE TOLD YOU HAPPENED?

5

       A      THAT'S CORRECT, THAT IS WHAT HE TOLD US.

6

       Q      AND WHAT DID MR. BROWN SAY HAPPENED ONCE

7

THEY GOT TO THE PARKING LOT AT ABALONE COVE?

8

       A      HE TOLD US ONCE AT ABALONE COVE, AFTER HE

9

REACHED HIS WIFE, THEY WALKED DOWN TO A PLAYGROUND AREA

10

ON THE BEACH.

11

       Q      AND DID HE SAY HOW THEY GOT DOWN TO THE

12

PLAYGROUND AREA, WHAT ROUTE THEY TOOK?

13

       A      HE SAID THAT THEY HIKED.  THEY HIKED THE

14

TRAILS DOWN TO THE PLAYGROUND AREA.

15

       Q      AND YOU TOLD US YESTERDAY THAT THERE IS, IN

16

FACT, A PLAYGROUND AREA DOWN ON THE BEACH BELOW ABALONE

17

COVE, CORRECT?

18

       A      THAT IS INCORPORATED INTO THE PRESCHOOL,

19

YES.

20

       Q      AND WHAT DID MR. BROWN TELL YOU HAPPENED

21

THEN?

22

       A      HE SAID THAT THEY ARRIVED AT ABOUT 1:30,

23

1:45, AND LAUREN PLAYED AT THE PLAYGROUND FOR ABOUT 20

24

MINUTES.

25

       Q      AND THEN WHAT DID MR. BROWN SAY HAPPENED?

26

       A      HE SAID AT THAT POINT SHE JUST WANTED TO

27

HIKE AND BEGAN HIKING.

28

       Q      SO HE INDICATED TO YOU THAT IT WAS LAUREN'S

176

1

IDEA TO START HIKING?

2

       A      ABSOLUTELY.  HE TOLD US UNEQUIVOCALLY THAT

3

IT WAS LAUREN'S IDEA TO BEGIN HIKING.

4

       Q      AND WHAT DID HE SAY ABOUT THE HIKING?

5

       A      HE SAID THAT SHE JUST STARTED HIKING.  HE

6

WAS HAVING DIFFICULTY KEEPING UP WITH HER, SHE WAS FAR

7

TOO ENERGETIC, AND HE WAS HAVING TO -- COULD NOT HOLD HER

8

BACK, IS THE WORDS THAT HE TOLD US.

9

              HE ALSO TOLD US THAT, AS THEY BEGAN HIKING,

10

SOME OF THE TRAILS WERE RATHER STEEP AND THAT HE WAS

11

ATTEMPTING TO HOLD HER HAND, AS HE WAS CONCERNED WITH HER

12

DUE TO THE STEEPNESS.

13

       Q      HE SAID HE HAD TROUBLE KEEPING UP WITH HER?

14

       A      THAT'S CORRECT.

15

       Q      AT SOME POINT LATER IN THE INTERVIEW DID

16

MR. BROWN TELL YOU ABOUT HIS PHYSICAL CONDITION?

17

       A      YES, HE DID.

18

       Q      WHAT DID HE TELL YOU ABOUT WHAT KIND OF

19

SHAPE HE WAS IN?

20

       A      ASIDE FROM THROWING LUGGAGE ALL DAY LONG AT

21

THE AIRLINES WHERE HE WORKS, HE ALSO TOLD US THAT HE

22

SURFS DAILY AND PRIOR TO THAT HAD BEEN VERY INVOLVED

23

RUNNING MARATHONS, HOWEVER HAD SUBSIDED FROM THAT

24

STRENUOUS TYPE OF RUNNING DUE TO A LOWER BACK INJURY.

25

       Q      WHAT DID MR. BROWN TELL YOU OCCURRED AS

26

THEY WERE HIKING?  WHERE DID THEY GO?

27

       A      HE SAID PRETTY MUCH THEY HIKED THE TRAILS

28

GOING TOWARDS INSPIRATION POINT AND THAT ALONG THE WAY

177

1

LAUREN WAS OUT IN FRONT OF HIM AS HE WAS TRYING TO KEEP

2

UP AND WAS THROWING ROCKS OFF THE TRAILS.

3

       Q      AND DID HE SAY, IN FACT, THAT THEY

4

EVENTUALLY MADE THEIR WAY TO INSPIRATION POINT?

5

       A      YES, HE DID.

6

       Q      AND DID HE SAY WHOSE IDEA IT WAS TO GO OUT

7

ONTO INSPIRATION POINT?

8

       A      HIS WORDS WERE, "SHE WANTED TO GO OUT

9

THERE."

10

       Q      AND DID MR. BROWN TELL YOU WHY LAUREN SAID

11

SHE WANTED TO GO OUT ONTO INSPIRATION POINT?

12

       A      TO ENJOY THE VIEW.

13

       Q      WHAT DID MR. BROWN TELL YOU HAPPENED ONCE

14

THEY GOT OUT ONTO INSPIRATION POINT?

15

       A      HE TOLD US THAT THEY ARRIVED AT THE POINT

16

AND THAT HE WAS IN A SEATED POSITION, HE SAID FOUR FEET

17

FROM THE EDGE.  HE TOLD US THAT THEY HAD STOPPED AND SAT

18

IN THE AREA WHERE, WHAT HE DESCRIBED AS, IT MAKES A

19

U-SHAPE.  HE SAID THAT THEY WERE SEATED -- OR HE WAS

20

SEATED FOUR FEET FROM THE EDGE OF THE CLIFF; THEY WERE

21

LOOKING AT THE VIEW, THE BOATS OFFSHORE; LAUREN WAS OUT

22

IN FRONT OF HIM, ALONG THE LEFT SIDE OF HIM, BACK BEHIND

23

HIM AT ONE POINT AND THEN OFF TO HIS RIGHT SIDE AT

24

ANOTHER POINT.  AND I BELIEVE HE SAID THEY SAT FOR FIVE

25

OR 10 MINUTES.

26

       Q      AND THEN WHAT DID MR. BROWN CLAIM HAPPENED?

27

       A      HE SAID THAT HE WAS POINTING DIFFERENT

28

AREAS OF INTEREST OUT TO THE FOUR YEAR OLD.  HE TOLD US

178

1

THAT HE HAD POINTED OFF TO HIS LEFT AND WAS POINTING OUT

2

TO THE FOUR-YEAR-OLD LITTLE GIRL WHERE PORTUGUESE BEND

3

CLUB WAS, CATALINA AND, I BELIEVE HE SAID, WHERE

4

MARINELAND USED TO BE.

5

       Q      AND WHAT DID MR. BROWN CLAIM HAPPENED THEN?

6

       A      THE FIRST TIME THAT WE WENT OVER IT HE SAID

7

THAT AS HE WAS LOOKING OFF TO HIS LEFT, HE ONLY LOOKED

8

AWAY FOR A SPLIT SECOND, AND HE HEARD A NERVOUS "AH" AND

9

LAUREN WAS GONE, HAD VANISHED.

10

       Q      AND SUBSEQUENT TO GIVING THAT EXPLANATION

11

DID HE GIVE A SLIGHTLY DIFFERENT VERSION OF WHAT HAD

12

OCCURRED?

13

       A      YES.  THROUGHOUT THE INTERVIEW WE HAD HIM

14

READDRESS HIS POSITIONING, WHAT TRANSPIRED, THE ACTIONS

15

WITH THE CHILD, THE INTERACTION BETWEEN HIM AND THE

16

CHILD.

17

              AND ON THE SECOND OCCASION THAT HE

18

ADDRESSED WHAT HAPPENED RIGHT BEFORE SHE WENT OVER THE

19

CLIFF HE TOLD US ON THAT ACCOUNT THAT HE HEARD A NERVOUS

20

"AH" AS HE WAS LOOKING OFF TO HIS LEFT; HE LOOKED BACK

21

AND SAW THE CHILD'S FEET AS SHE WAS GOING OVER THE CLIFF

22

AND HAD SURMISED THAT SHE HAD LOST HER BALANCE.

23

       Q      AND DID HE TELL YOU WHETHER OR NOT SHE WAS

24

GOING HEAD FIRST OR FEET FIRST?

25

       A      HEAD FIRST.

26

       Q      OKAY.  DETECTIVE, LET ME ASK YOU THIS:  WAS

27

THERE A REASON WHY YOU HAD MR. BROWN GO OVER HIS VERSION

28

OF WHAT HAD OCCURRED MORE THAN ONCE?

179

1

       A      THERE WERE A COUPLE OF DIFFERENT REASONS,

2

YES.

3

       Q      AND WHAT WOULD THAT BE?

4

       A      I THINK ONE OF THE FIRST THINGS WAS HIS

5

LACK OF EMOTION.  HIS BEHAVIOR, HIS ATTITUDE, HIS MAKEUP

6

JUST WAS COMPLETELY INCONSISTENT WITH -- IN MY OPINION

7

WAS INCONSISTENT WITH WHAT HAD JUST TRANSPIRED.

8

              THERE WERE SEVERAL THINGS THAT STUCK OUT AS

9

FAR AS THE ROUTE THAT THEY HAD TAKEN, THE LENGTH OF TIME

10

THAT A FOUR-YEAR-OLD GIRL HAD WALKED, AND JUST THE

11

GENERAL AREA IN AND OF ITSELF, AND WHAT SEEMED TO BE A

12

LACK OF PARENTAL CONCERN OVER SAFETY ISSUES.  IT JUST

13

DIDN'T SEEM TO QUITE BE ADDING UP.

14

       Q      OKAY.  AND SO YOU ASKED HIM ABOUT THIS

15

VARIOUS TIMES BECAUSE YOU WANTED TO SEE IF THE STORIES

16

WERE CONSISTENT OR JUST BECAUSE IT DIDN'T MAKE SENSE?

17

       A      I FELT AS IF HE WAS LYING TO US.

18

       Q      AFTER HE GAVE YOU WHAT YOU HAVE REFERRED TO

19

AS THE SECOND VERSION, DID YOU ASK HIM AT SOME POINT TO

20

GO OVER IT AGAIN?

21

       A      YES, I DID.

22

       Q      AND WHAT DID MR. BROWN TELL YOU THIS TIME?

23

       A      ON THAT -- AT THAT TIME IN THE INTERVIEW HE

24

AGAIN SAID THAT HE WAS LOOKING OFF TO HIS LEFT; HE

25

RECALLED ACTUALLY POINTING TO HIS LEFT AT THE PORTUGUESE

26

BEND CLUB OR WHERE MARINELAND USED TO BE, ONE OF THE TWO;

27

HE SAID HE HEARD HER SAY, "OH, OH," AND HE LOOKED BACK,

28

AND THIS TIME HE SAW HER UPPER BODY FROM THE BACK AND

180

1

BASICALLY THE LEFT SIDE, HE DESCRIBED SEEING THE LEFT

2

SIDE OF THE YOUNG GIRL, GOING FORWARD AND GO OVER THE

3

CLIFF HEAD FIRST, AND AT THAT POINT HAD SURMISED TO US,

4

AS IF SHE WAS THROWING A ROCK AND HAD HURLED HERSELF

5

FORWARD.

6

       Q      DID MR. BROWN INDICATE TO YOU WHETHER OR

7

NOT HE COULD SEE WHERE SHE LANDED OR IF HE COULD SEE DOWN

8

THE CLIFF?

9

       A      HE SAID HE COULD NOT SEE, HE DID NOT HEAR

10

AND HE COULD NOT -- HE DID NOT HEAR HER HIT THE BOTTOM.

11

HE HEARD NOTHING MORE FROM HER AND HE COULD NOT SEE, ONCE

12

SHE WENT OVER, WHERE SHE HAD LANDED.

13

       Q      WHAT DID MR. BROWN SAY HE DID AFTER LAUREN

14

WENT OVER THE CLIFF?

15

       A      AFTER SHE WENT OVER THE CLIFF, HE TOLD US

16

THAT HE THEN RAN BACK INLAND AND TO THE LEFT SIDE OF

17

INSPIRATION POINT, DOWN TO THE NUDE BEACH, LOOKING FOR

18

SOMEBODY THAT HAD A CELLULAR TELEPHONE.

19

       Q      NOW, YOU DESCRIBED FOR US IN SOME FAIRLY

20

SIGNIFICANT DETAIL YESTERDAY THE SHAPE OF INSPIRATION

21

POINT AND SPECIFICALLY THAT THERE IS SORT OF LIKE A

22

NARROW NECK AREA THAT YOU HAVE TO GO THROUGH IF YOU ARE

23

COMING FROM THE ROAD BEFORE INSPIRATION POINT KIND OF

24

WIDENS OUT A LITTLE BIT; IS THAT CORRECT?

25

       A      THAT'S CORRECT.

26

       Q      NOW, IN ORDER TO GET TO THE TRAILS THAT

27

LEAD OFF OF INSPIRATION POINT, DO YOU HAVE TO GO THROUGH

28

THIS NECK AREA, BACK TOWARDS THE ROAD, BEFORE YOU CAN

181

1

ACCESS ANY TRAILS TO GO DOWN?

2

       A      YES, THAT'S ACCURATE.  IN FACT, THAT IS

3

WHAT HE HAD TOLD US HE DID, IS RUN THROUGH THAT NARROW

4

AREA AND THEN OFF TO THE LEFT, DOWN TO THE NUDE BEACH.

5

       Q      AND WHAT DID MR. BROWN SAY THAT HE DID AS

6

HE GOT DOWN TO THE NUDE BEACH?

7

       A      HE SAID THAT HE HOLLERED OUT FOR ANYBODY

8

WITH A CELLPHONE.

9

       Q      AND DID MR. BROWN INDICATE WHETHER HE GOT A

10

CELLPHONE?

11

       A      YES, HE DID.

12

       Q      WHAT DID HE SAY ABOUT THAT?

13

       A      HE SAID HE OBTAINED THE CELLPHONE FROM A

14

GENTLEMAN WHO WAS ON THE BEACH AND WAS IN THE PROCESS OF

15

TRYING TO FIND RECEPTION ON THE CELLULAR TELEPHONE BY

16

MOVING AROUND THE BEACH AREA, HE ULTIMATELY DID THAT AND,

17

AS HE DIALED 911, THE END VERBIAGE WAS, ASKED THE

18

GENTLEMAN WHO LOANED HIM THE CELLPHONE TO GO AND LOOK FOR

19

HIS DAUGHTER.

20

       Q      AND DID MR. BROWN INDICATE THAT HE, IN

21

FACT, CONNECTED WITH THE 911 CALL AND REQUESTED HELP?

22

       A      YES, HE CONNECTED WITH THE CALIFORNIA

23

HIGHWAY PATROL, WHICH IS WHERE CELLULAR 911 CALLS GO, AND

24

TOLD THE 911 OPERATOR THAT HIS DAUGHTER HAD FALLEN FROM A

25

CLIFF IN RANCHO PALOS VERDES.

26

       Q      AND DID HE ALSO SAY HE SPOKE WITH THE FIRE

27

DEPARTMENT RESCUE PEOPLE?

28

       A      HE SAID HE SPOKE WITH SOMEBODY ELSE, AND HE

182

1

BELIEVED IT TO BE THE FIRE DEPARTMENT.

2

       Q      AND WHAT DID MR. BROWN INDICATE HE DID

3

AFTER HE COMPLETED THE 911 CALL?

4

       A      AFTER COMPLETING THE 911 CALL HE RETURNED

5

THE TELEPHONE TO THE PERSON WHOM HE HAD BORROWED IT FROM,

6

THAT PERSON HAD RETURNED TO THE BEACH AREA; HE THEN RAN,

7

HE SAID, AS HARD AS HE COULD UP THE TRAIL, GOING BACK TO

8

THE TOP OF INSPIRATION POINT, DOWN THE OTHER SIDE, WHICH

9

IS IN THE GENERAL AREA WHERE THE ARCHERY CLUB WOULD BE,

10

AND THEN ALONG THE EAST SIDE OF INSPIRATION POINT OUT TO

11

THE ROCKS, WHERE HE SAW HIS DAUGHTER FLOATING FACE DOWN

12

IN THE INLET.

13

       Q      DID MR. BROWN INDICATE TO YOU AT ALL THAT

14

AFTER HE MADE THE 911 CALL HE TRIED TO TRAVEL ALONG THE

15

BASE OF INSPIRATION POINT FROM WHERE HE WAS RATHER THAN

16

GOING ALL THE WAY BACK UP OVER THE CLIFF?  DID HE SAY

17

FIRST HE TRIED TO GO AROUND THE OCEAN SIDE, AROUND THE

18

BASE OF THE CLIFF, TO GET TO HER?

19

       A      NO, HE DID NOT TRY TO GO AROUND THE OCEAN

20

SIDE.

21

       Q      WHAT DID MR. BROWN INDICATE TO YOU THAT HE

22

DID AFTER HE ARRIVED AT THE INLET AND SAW HIS DAUGHTER'S

23

BODY FLOATING FACE DOWN IN THE WATER?

24

              FIRST, WHERE DID HE SAY HER BODY WAS

25

FLOATING FACE DOWN IN THE WATER?

26

       A      HE SAID SHE WAS FLOATING IN THE INLET,

27

WHICH WOULD BE THE FURTHEST EAST INLET.  SHE WAS ABOUT

28

TWO-THIRDS OF THE WAY TOWARDS THE OCEAN FROM WHAT HE

183

1

DESCRIBED AS THE FLAT ROCKS.

2

       Q      AND SO WHEN MR. BROWN SAW HIS DAUGHTER

3

FLOATING FACE DOWN IN THE INLET, WHAT DID HE SAY HE DID?

4

       A      HE TOOK HIS CLOTHING OFF.

5

       Q      AND WHAT CLOTHING DID HE SAY HE TOOK OFF?

6

       A      HE REMOVED HIS FLANNEL OVERSHIRT, HIS

7

T-SHIRT AND HIS SHORTS, OR WALKING SHORTS -- I CALL THEM

8

WALKING SHORTS -- AND PLACED THEM ON THE ROCKS.

9

       Q      AND DID MR. BROWN INDICATE TO YOU WHY, WHEN

10

HIS DAUGHTER IS FLOATING IN THE WATER, HE DECIDES TO GET

11

UNDRESSED?

12

       A      YES, HE DID.

13

       Q      AND WHAT DID HE SAY ABOUT THAT?

14

       A      HE SAID THAT HE HAD SEEN IT ON THE

15

TELEVISION PROGRAM "BAYWATCH" AND THAT HE DID NOT WANT TO

16

BE WET OR COLD LATER ON.

17

       Q      WHAT DID MR. BROWN INDICATE THAT HE DID

18

AFTER HE TOOK OFF MOST OF HIS CLOTHES WHEN HE SAW LAUREN

19

FLOATING IN THE WATER?

20

       A      HE SAID THAT HE WAS DRESSED IN ONLY HIS

21

BOXER SHORTS AND HIS SHOES, THEN ENTERED THE WATER, SWAM

22

OUT TO WHERE LAUREN'S BODY WAS, PULLED HER TOWARDS THE

23

EAST ROCK LINE AT THE INLET, SET HER ON TOP OF A FLAT

24

ROCK AND THEN CLIMBED OUT OF THE WATER.

25

       Q      AND WHAT DID HE INDICATE HE DID THEN?

26

       A      HE THEN SAID THAT HE PERFORMED C.P.R.,

27

CARDIOPULMONARY RESUSCITATION, ON THE CHILD, AND HE

28

ESTIMATED THAT IT WAS ABOUT ONE MINUTE.

184

1

       Q      AND THEN WHAT DID HE SAY HE DID?

2

       A      HE THEN TOLD US THAT HE REMOVED HIS WET

3

BOXER SHORTS, FLUNG THEM WITH HIS FOOT, TELLING US THAT

4

WE WOULD STILL FIND THEM THERE -- AND THE BLUE BOXER

5

SHORTS DID, IN FACT, BELONG TO HIM -- HE PUT HIS SHORTS

6

BACK ON, HE PLACED HIS T-SHIRT BACK ON AND TIED HIS

7

FLANNEL SHIRT AROUND HIS WAIST.

8

       Q      AND THIS IS WHILE LAUREN IS ON THE ROCKS?

9

       A      THIS IS WHILE LAUREN IS LAYING ON THE ROCKS

10

ADJACENT TO THE INLET, YES.

11

       Q      AND THEN WHAT DID MR. BROWN SAY HE DID?

12

       A      HE SAID HE PICKED HER UP, PUT HER OVER HIS

13

LEFT SHOULDER AND BEGAN RUNNING TO WHERE THE PARAMEDICS

14

WOULD BE COMING.

15

       Q      AND WHAT DID HE SAY OCCURRED AS HE WAS

16

RUNNING BACK TOWARDS WHERE THE PARAMEDICS WERE GOING TO

17

BE COMING?

18

       A      HE TOLD US THAT HE FELT WETNESS ON HIS BACK

19

AND THAT HE WAS BECOMING BLOOD SOAKED ON THE BACK OF HIS

20

SHIRT, SO HE PUT THE CHILD IN FRONT OF HIM AND CARRIED

21

HER BASICALLY IN A CRADLE POSITION FOR THE REMAINDER OF

22

THE DISTANCE THAT HE TRAVELED TO THE ARCHERY RANGE.

23

       Q      AND WHAT DID MR. BROWN SAY HE DID WHEN HE

24

GOT TO THE ARCHERY RANGE?

25

       A      HE HAD ACTUALLY MET UP WITH A GENTLEMAN

26

THERE; I BELIEVE THEY HAD A BRIEF CONVERSATION, AND HE

27

TOLD THIS PERSON THAT HE WAS GOING TO SET THE CHILD ON

28

THE TABLES.  HE PROCEEDED TO A COVERED AWNING AREA.  I

185

1

CALLED IT A PICNIC AREA.  IT HAD THREE LONG TABLES AND

2

BENCHES.  AND HE PLACED HER ON THE TABLE AND, HIS WORDS

3

WERE, STRAIGHTENED HER OUT, WHICH TO ME IS POSITIONING --

4

HE STRAIGHTENED HER ARMS AND HER LEGS AND LAID HER ON THE

5

PICNIC TABLE.

6

       Q      ARE THERE PICNIC TABLES OUT THERE THAT

7

AREN'T UNDER ANY KIND OF A COVERING?

8

       A      YEAH, THERE ARE.  THERE WERE A COUPLE THAT

9

WERE SET OFF TO THE SIDE.

10

       Q      DID MR. BROWN INDICATE HOW LONG IT TOOK THE

11

PARAMEDICS TO GET THERE AFTER HE HAD SET LAUREN ON THE

12

PICNIC TABLE?

13

       A      THREE MINUTES.

14

       Q      DID YOU ASK MR. BROWN WHETHER OR NOT HE

15

TRIED TO PERFORM C.P.R. WHILE SHE WAS ON THE PICNIC TABLE

16

AND THERE WAS ACTUALLY SOMEONE ELSE PRESENT?

17

       A      YES, I DID.

18

       Q      WHAT DID HE SAY ABOUT THAT?

19

       A      HE TOLD US HE DID NOT HAVE TIME.

20

       Q      I THINK YOU INDICATED THAT MR. BROWN TOLD

21

YOU THEY HAD BEEN OUT ON INSPIRATION POINT FOR ABOUT HOW

22

LONG BEFORE LAUREN WENT OVER THE CLIFF?

23

       A      HE SAID THEY WERE OUT THERE FOR ABOUT 15

24

MINUTES AND HAD BEEN -- 10 TO 15 MINUTES AND HAD BEEN

25

SEATED FOR ABOUT FIVE, I BELIEVE IS WHAT HE SAID.

26

       Q      DID MR. BROWN INDICATE TO YOU ABOUT HOW

27

LONG IT TOOK HIM FROM THE TIME LAUREN WENT OVER THE CLIFF

28

UNTIL HE GOT TO HER BODY FLOATING IN THE WATER?

186

1

       A      ANOTHER 10 MINUTES.

2

       Q      DID YOU ASK MR. BROWN ANY QUESTIONS ABOUT

3

HIS STATEMENT THAT AFTER HE USED THE CELLPHONE HE RAN AS

4

HARD AS HE COULD BACK UP THE CLIFF, DOWN THE OTHER SIDE,

5

ON THE ARCHERY RANGE SIDE, AND THEN OUT TO THE POINT

6

WHERE LAUREN'S BODY WAS FOUND?

7

       A      YES, I DID.

8

       Q      AND WHY DID YOU ASK HIM QUESTIONS ABOUT

9

THAT?

10

       A      I HAD BEEN THERE, I HAD TRAVERSED THAT

11

AREA.  BELIEVE IT OR NOT, I ALSO ACTUALLY USED TO DO SOME

12

RUNNING AND TRAIL RUNNING; AND I KNOW THAT IT IS VERY

13

EASY, ESPECIALLY WHEN YOU ARE RUNNING, TO LOSE YOUR

14

BALANCE AND TRIP AND FALL, WHICH WOULD BE EXPECTED IF YOU

15

ARE RUNNING AS HARD AS YOU COULD, WHICH WOULD BE EXPECTED

16

IN THAT GIVEN CIRCUMSTANCE SINCE THE AREA THAT YOU WOULD

17

HAVE TO TRAVERSE HAS VERY SHARP ANGLED ROCKS.  IT IS VERY

18

UNEVEN, VERY UNSTEADY FOOTING.

19

              I WOULD EXPECT OR EXPECTED TO SEE CUTS,

20

ABRASIONS ON THE SHINS, KNEES, EVEN THE HANDS IF YOU ARE

21

REALLY, REALLY TRYING TO MAKE YOUR WAY THROUGH THAT AREA

22

AS FAST AS YOU COULD; AND I DID NOT SEE ANY OF THAT.

23

       Q      ON MR. BROWN?

24

       A      ON MR. BROWN.

25

       Q      DID YOU ASK HIM ABOUT THAT?

26

       A      I DID.

27

       Q      AND WHAT DID HE SAY?

28

       A      HIS RESPONSE WAS, "WELL, I WAS RUNNING AS

187

1

FAST AS I COULD, BUT I WAS WATCHING MY FOOTING."

2

       Q      DID YOU ASK MR. BROWN WHETHER OR NOT HE

3

SCREAMED OR YELLED WHEN LAUREN WENT OVER THE CLIFF?

4

       A      I DID.

5

       Q      AND WHAT DID HE SAY ABOUT THAT?

6

       A      HE SAID NO.

7

       Q      WHAT DID YOU SAY WHEN HE GAVE YOU THAT

8

RESPONSE?

9

       A      I THINK AT THAT POINT IN THE INTERVIEW BOTH

10

MY PARTNER AND I PRETTY MUCH IN UNISON SAID THAT, BOTH

11

HAVING CHILDREN, WE WOULD BOTH BE SCREAMING BLOODY MURDER

12

HAD IT BEEN OUR CHILDREN WHO HAD SLIPPED AND FALLEN.

13

              HE SEEMED TO PONDER ON THAT MOMENTARILY AND

14

THEN TOLD US, "I THINK I MAY HAVE CALLED HER NAME."

15

       Q      DID YOU ASK MR. BROWN WHY HE WOULD TAKE HIS

16

DAUGHTER, HIS FOUR-YEAR-OLD DAUGHTER, OUT TO SUCH A

17

DANGEROUS PLACE?

18

       A      YES, I DID.

19

       Q      AND WHAT DID HE SAY ABOUT THAT?

20

       A      HIS RESPONSE WAS VERY INTERESTING.  WHAT HE

21

TOLD ME WAS THE WHOLE PLACE IS DANGEROUS, IT'S NICE, IT'S

22

STEEP, THE CLIFFS, AND THEN HE SEEMED JUST TO FADE OFF

23

AND NEVER FINISH THE THOUGHT OR THE SENTENCE, AT LEAST

24

AUDIBLY.

25

       Q      DID YOU ASK MR. BROWN WHETHER OR NOT THERE

26

WAS ANYONE ELSE OUT ON INSPIRATION POINT AT THE TIME THAT

27

MAY HAVE SEEN WHAT HAD HAPPENED?

28

       A      YES, I DID.

188

1

       Q      WHAT DID HE SAY ABOUT THAT?

2

       A      HE SAID THAT HE DID NOT BELIEVE ANYBODY

3

ELSE WAS OUT THERE.

4

       Q      DID MR. BROWN ALSO INDICATE TO YOU THAT HE

5

HAD SOME TYPE OF A CAMERA?

6

       A      YES, HE DID.

7

       Q      TELL US HOW THAT CAME UP.

8

       A      THAT WAS TOLD TO US BY THE HANDLING PATROL

9

DEPUTIES.  DEPUTIES GIRMES AND BROTHERS HAD INDICATED

10

THAT HE HAD BROUGHT THAT TO THEIR ATTENTION WHEN THEY HAD

11

ORIGINALLY CONTACTED HIM.

12

              AND HE HAD ALSO TOLD US WHEN QUESTIONED,

13

YES, THAT HE DID HAVE A CAMERA, HE HAD TAKEN WHAT HE

14

BELIEVED TO BE FOUR PHOTOGRAPHS OF LAUREN; THEY WERE

15

ENJOYING THE DAY, THEY WERE RELAXING, AND THESE

16

PHOTOGRAPHS WOULD PROVE TO US THAT -- OR WOULD SHOW US

17

THAT SHE WAS HAPPY, THEY WERE HAVING A GOOD TIME AND THEY

18

WERE JUST OUT FOR A LEISURELY DAY.

19

       Q      AND DID YOU HAVE THOSE PICTURES DEVELOPED?

20

       A      YES, I DID.

21

       Q      HOW MANY TOTAL PHOTOS COULD HAVE BEEN TAKEN

22

ON THIS DISPOSABLE CAMERA?

23

       A      TWENTY-SEVEN.

24

       Q      AND WERE THERE SOME -- WERE THERE ANY

25

PHOTOS OF LAUREN?

26

       A      YES.

27

       Q      AND HOW MANY?

28

       A      THREE.

189

1

       Q      PRIOR TO THE PHOTOS OF LAUREN WERE THERE

2

OTHER PHOTOS?

3

       A      YES.

4

       Q      AND WHAT WERE THOSE OF?

5

       A      THIRTEEN PHOTOGRAPHS OF -- WELL, A COUPLE

6

WERE BLURRY AND YOU COULDN'T TELL WHAT THEY WERE; AND

7

THEN THERE WERE 13 PHOTOGRAPHS OF CAMERON LOADING

8

SURFBOARDS ONTO A SUBARU STATION WAGON; HIS FATHER WITH

9

SOME SURFBOARDS.  JUST BASICALLY HIM AND HIS FATHER.

10

       Q      OKAY.  AND THEN THERE WERE THREE PHOTOS OF

11

LAUREN?

12

       A      THREE PHOTOGRAPHS OF LAUREN THAT WERE TAKEN

13

THAT DAY.

14

       Q      AND WHERE WERE THOSE PHOTOGRAPHS TAKEN?

15

COULD YOU TELL FROM THE PHOTOS?

16

       A      YES.  YES.  HAVING BEEN THERE, YES.

17

       Q      WHERE WERE THEY TAKEN?

18

       A      THE FIRST PHOTOGRAPH WAS TAKEN AT THE

19

ABALONE COVE PARKING LOT IN VERY, VERY CLOSE PROXIMITY TO

20

WHERE HE PARKED HIS CAR AND NEAR THE PAY TELEPHONE THAT'S

21

AT THE EAST END OF THE ABALONE COVE SHORELINE PARK

22

PARKING AREA.

23

       Q      AND WHAT ABOUT THE OTHER TWO?

24

       A      THE SECOND PHOTOGRAPH WAS TAKEN AS YOU

25

DESCEND THE STEEP LITTLE TRAIL THAT GOES FROM THE ABALONE

26

COVE PARKING LOT.  AT ONE POINT THAT TRAIL JOINS WITH THE

27

ROAD THAT YOU COULD ACTUALLY ACCESS IF THE SCHOOL IS OPEN

28

OFF PALOS VERDES DRIVE SOUTH.  THEY MAKE KIND OF A

190

1

T-INTERSECTION, THE TRAIL AND THE ROAD.  AND JUST ON THE

2

OTHER SIDE OF THE ROAD THERE IS A FLAT AREA WITH A LARGE

3

BUSH AND THEN THE BEACH WOULD BE BEHIND AND BELOW YOU.

4

AND THERE WAS A PHOTOGRAPH OF LAUREN TAKEN AT THAT POINT.

5

       Q      AND THEN WHAT ABOUT THE THIRD ONE?

6

       A      THE THIRD PHOTOGRAPH WAS ACTUALLY TAKEN AT

7

THE PRESCHOOL PLAYGROUND AREA ITSELF.  AND IN THAT

8

PARTICULAR PHOTOGRAPH LAUREN IS IN A TUBE OR TUNNEL, AND

9

YOU CAN PARTIALLY SEE HER AS SHE IS CLIMBING THROUGH OR

10

LOOKING OUT.

11

       Q      AND WHAT WERE HER EXPRESSIONS LIKE IN

12

THOSE?  DID SHE SEEM LIKE SHE WAS CRYING?  DID SHE SEEM

13

JUST NONCHALANT OR HAPPY, LAUGHING?

14

       A      NO, SHE WAS NOT CRYING.  SHE WAS NOT HAPPY.

15

SHE WAS NOT LAUGHING.  SHE SEEMED ALMOST RATHER

16

INDIFFERENT, UNEASY.  IN THE PICTURE -- AND, AGAIN, I AM

17

GOING OFF MY PERCEPTION OF THE PHOTOGRAPH BUT, IN

18

PARTICULAR, THE PICTURE IN THE TUNNEL TO ME SHE ALMOST

19

LOOKS WARY OR UNEASY OR SCARED.

20

       Q      DO THEY APPEAR TO YOU TO DEPICT A HAPPY

21

CHILD?

22

       A      NO.  NO.

23

       Q      NOW, WERE THERE ADDITIONAL -- WAS THERE

24

ADDITIONAL FILM THAT MORE PHOTOGRAPHS COULD HAVE BEEN

25

TAKEN ON THAT CAMERA?

26

       A      YES, THERE WERE SEVERAL PHOTOGRAPHS

27

REMAINING UNEXPOSED.

28

       Q      WERE THERE ANY FURTHER PHOTOGRAPHS AFTER

191

1

THE PLAYGROUND?

2

       A      THERE WAS NO PICTURES TAKEN AFTER THEY LEFT

3

THE PLAYGROUND.

4

       Q      SO NOTHING OF THE HIKES?

5

       A      NO.

6

       Q      NOTHING ON INSPIRATION POINT?

7

       A      NOTHING ON INSPIRATION POINT, NOTHING ON

8

THE VIEW THAT THEY WERE ENJOYING, NOTHING ONCE THEY LEFT

9

THE PLAYGROUND AREA.

10

       Q      NOW, YOU MENTIONED A LITTLE BIT EARLIER

11

THAT ONE OF THE THINGS THAT CAUGHT YOUR ATTENTION WAS

12

MR. BROWN'S DEMEANOR.  CAN YOU DESCRIBE FOR US

13

MR. BROWN'S DEMEANOR DURING THIS INTERVIEW?

14

              FIRST, HOW LONG DID THIS INTERVIEW TAKE,

15

WOULD YOU SAY, ABOUT?

16

       A      FOUR HOURS.

17

       Q      CAN YOU DESCRIBE HIS DEMEANOR DURING THIS

18

INTERVIEW?

19

       A      TO AN EXTENT.  I THINK I SAID YESTERDAY,

20

AND I REALLY TRULY BELIEVE THAT THAT'S THE BEST WAY TO

21

DESCRIBE IT, JUST A TOTAL LACK OF EMOTION, A TOTAL LACK

22

OF RESPONSIBILITY, ALMOST UNATTACHED.  IT JUST WAS NOT

23

APPROPRIATE FOR THE CIRCUMSTANCES WHICH WE WERE

24

DISCUSSING.

25

              IN MY EXPERIENCE -- AND I HAVE TALKED TO A

26

LOT OF GRIEVING FAMILY MEMBERS OVER THE LAST SIX YEARS --

27

IRREGARDLESS OF HOW A CHILD DIES, IT SEEMS TO ME, AT

28

LEAST HAS BEEN MY EXPERIENCE, THAT PARENTS ALWAYS BLAME

192

1

THEMSELVES.  HOWEVER FAR REMOVED THEIR ROLE WAS, THEY

2

BLAME THEMSELVES FOR SOMETHING, LETTING THE KID GO TO

3

SCHOOL THAT DAY, LETTING THE KID DO WHATEVER, WALK TO THE

4

POOL, WHATEVER IT WAS.  THERE IS A RESPONSIBILITY THERE;

5

THERE IS A BLAME, THEY BLAME THEMSELVES.

6

              AND THERE WAS JUST ABSOLUTELY NO EMOTION,

7

NO RESPONSIBILITY, NO GUILT, NO -- THERE WAS NOTHING.  IT

8

WAS JUST VERY, VERY "LET'S GET THROUGH THIS" AND VERY, I

9

WANT TO SAY, MATTER OF FACT; BUT THERE WAS NOT EVEN THAT

10

EMOTION.  IT WAS JUST GOING THROUGH THE MOTIONS, IF YOU

11

WILL.

12

       Q      DID MR. BROWN EVER CRY OR EXPRESS REMORSE

13

DURING YOUR INTERVIEW?

14

       A      NOT AT ALL.

15

       Q      DID HE EVER USE LAUREN'S NAME DURING THE

16

INTERVIEW?

17

       A      NO.  IN FACT, THAT WAS THE ONE THING THAT

18

DAWNED ON ME OR HIT ME THE HARDEST.  WE HAD BEEN TALKING

19

FOR SEVERAL HOURS AND HAD ACTUALLY CONFRONTED HIM AT THAT

20

POINT WITH "WE BELIEVE THAT YOU'RE LYING.  WITNESSES WHO

21

SAW THIS INCIDENT, YOUR STORY DOESN'T CORRELATE TO WHAT

22

THEY WERE SAYING," AND HAD ACTUALLY CONFRONTED HIM WITH

23

LYING AND BEING RESPONSIBLE AND AT FAULT FOR THIS.

24

              AND IT DAWNED ON ME THAT IN SPEAKING IN

25

THREE, THREE-AND-A-HALF, FOUR HOURS, HE NEVER ONCE CALLED

26

THIS LITTLE GIRL BY HER NAME.  HE ALWAYS REFERRED TO HER

27

THROUGHOUT THE ENTIRE CONVERSATION AS HER OR SHE, "SHE

28

DID THIS"; "I TOLD HER THIS."  NEVER ONCE DID HE SAY HER

193

1

NAME.

2

       Q      DID MR. BROWN INDICATE ANYTHING TO YOU

3

ABOUT THE SHIRT THAT HE WAS WEARING?

4

       A      YES.

5

       Q      WHAT DID HE SAY ABOUT THAT?

6

       A      HE TOLD US THAT WE WERE MORE THAN WELCOME

7

TO HAVE IT.  I BELIEVE THAT WAS AT THE POINT WE WERE

8

PHOTOGRAPHING THE T-SHIRT.  AND HE BASICALLY SAID, "YOU

9

GUYS CAN HAVE THIS IF YOU WANT IT.  I AM JUST GOING TO

10

THROW IT AWAY."

11

       Q      DID YOU AT SOME POINT TOWARDS THE END OF

12

THE INTERVIEW CONFRONT MR. BROWN WITH THE FACT THAT IT

13

SEEMED REALLY ODD THAT HE WAS SHOWING ABSOLUTELY NO

14

EMOTION?

15

       A      YES.

16

       Q      AND WHAT DID MR. BROWN SAY ABOUT THAT?

17

       A      IT WAS ACTUALLY SEVERAL TIMES WE CONFRONTED

18

HIM WITH SHOWING NO EMOTION.  FINALLY HE CONCEDED TO US

19

THAT EARLIER HE HAD BEEN HYSTERICAL AND WAS NOT ABLE TO

20

STOP CRYING AND HAD BEEN CRYING VERY HEAVILY AND TOLD US

21

THAT THAT WAS DURING THE TIME THAT HE WAS ON THE

22

CELLPHONE MAKING THE CALL TO 911.

23

       Q      SO HE INDICATED TO YOU THAT DURING THE 911

24

CALL HE WAS CRYING HYSTERICALLY?

25

       A      COULD NOT STOP CRYING IS WHAT HE TOLD US.

26

       Q      DID YOU GET THE TAPE OF THAT 911 CALL?

27

       A      YES, I DID.

28

       Q      AND DO WE HAVE IT HERE IN COURT TODAY?

194

1

       A      YES, I BELIEVE WE DO.

2

       Q      DID YOU, TOWARDS THE END OF THE INTERVIEW,

3

ATTEMPT TO ELICIT SOME EMOTION FROM MR. BROWN BY SAYING

4

ANYTHING TO HIM OR DOING ANYTHING TO TRY AND ELICIT SOME

5

EMOTION OR SOME ACCEPTANCE OF RESPONSIBILITY?

6

       A      YES.

7

       Q      AND CAN YOU TELL US WHAT YOU DID?

8

       A      BOTH VERBALLY AND -- TELLING HIM THAT "YOU

9

HAVE TO TAKE RESPONSIBILITY FOR THIS.  YOU ARE THE ADULT

10

HERE.  THAT YOUNG GIRL IS YOUR RESPONSIBILITY."  IT

11

REALLY DIDN'T SEEM TO GO ANYWHERE.

12

              HE JUST KEPT SAYING, "NO, NO, NO.  IT WAS

13

HER IDEA, SHE WANTED TO GO OUT THERE.  I WAS JUST TRYING

14

TO KEEP UP WITH HER."

15

              WE THEN WENT TO TELLING HIM THAT HE HAD

16

THROWN, PUSHED, SHOVED HER OVER THE CLIFF.  AGAIN THERE

17

WAS NO EMOTIONAL RESPONSE.  IT WAS, "NO, I TOLD YOU WHAT

18

HAPPENED.  I SAW YOU WRITE IT DOWN RIGHT THERE IN YOUR

19

NOTEBOOK.  IT'S ALL THERE.  I TOLD YOU WHAT HAPPENED."

20

              ULTIMATELY, AND I GUESS I HAVE TO ADMIT A

21

LITTLE BIT OUT OF FRUSTRATION, WE PUT A POLAROID PICTURE

22

IN FRONT OF HIM OF LAUREN THAT WAS TAKEN BY THE L.A.

23

COUNTY CORONER AND PROVIDED TO US THAT NIGHT OF HER.  IT

24

WAS A FACE SHOT OF HER BLUNT-FORCE TRAUMA TO HER HEAD.

25

AND WE PLACED IT IN FRONT OF HIM AND TOLD HIM TO LOOK AT

26

IT.

27

       Q      AND WHAT WAS HIS RESPONSE?

28

       A      HE PICKED IT UP, AND HE LOOKED AND POINTED

195

1

AND SAID, "YEAH, THAT'S HER RIGHT THERE," AND SAT THE

2

PICTURE BACK IN FRONT OF HIM.

3

       Q      NOW, DETECTIVE LESLIE, YOU HAVE BEEN UP TO

4

THE TOP OF INSPIRATION POINT A NUMBER OF TIMES SINCE THIS

5

HAPPENED, CORRECT?

6

       A      YES, SEVERAL TIMES.

7

       Q      AND, AGAIN, AS YOU'RE STANDING ON

8

INSPIRATION POINT, THE ARCHERY RANGE WOULD BE TO YOUR

9

LEFT AS YOU ARE FACING THE OCEAN, CORRECT?

10

       A      THAT'S CORRECT.

11

       Q      AND THE NUDE BEACH, OR SACREDS COVE, WOULD

12

BE TO YOUR RIGHT; IS THAT CORRECT?

13

       A      YES, THAT'S CORRECT.

14

       Q      DID MR. BROWN EVER EXPLAIN TO YOU WHY IT

15

WAS THAT AFTER LAUREN WENT OVER THE CLIFF HE DIDN'T JUST

16

RUN TO THE SACREDS COVE SIDE OF THE CLIFF AND HOLLER DOWN

17

FOR THE PEOPLE DOWN BELOW TO CALL 911?

18

       A      THERE WAS NEVER ANY EXPLANATION PROVIDED.

19

       Q      HAVING BEEN UP THERE, IS THERE ANYTHING

20

THAT WOULD PREVENT SOMEONE FROM GOING TO THAT SIDE OF THE

21

CLIFF AND HOLLERING DOWN TO PEOPLE JUST BELOW ON THE

22

BEACH THAT THEY NEEDED HELP OR TO CALL 911?

23

       A      ABSOLUTELY NOTHING.

24

       Q      DID MR. BROWN EVER EXPLAIN TO YOU WHY IT

25

WAS THAT, AFTER LAUREN WENT OVER THE CLIFF, RATHER THAN

26

RUNNING BACK ACROSS THE NECK OF INSPIRATION POINT AND

27

GOING DOWN TO THE RIGHT SIDE SO THAT HE COULD ACCESS

28

LAUREN'S BODY, WHY IT WAS THAT INSTEAD HE FIRST WENT TO

196

1

THE LEFT, DOWN TO SACREDS COVE, TO GET A CELLPHONE BEFORE

2

HE WENT TO HER BODY?

3

       A      NO.

4

       Q      HE NEVER OFFERED ANY EXPLANATION FOR THAT?

5

       A      THE ONLY THING I CAN RECALL IS THAT I THINK

6

HE SAID HE SAW SOME PEOPLE DOWN THERE AS THEY HAD PASSED

7

EARLIER.

8

       Q      BUT HE NEVER EXPLAINED WHY HE DIDN'T TRY TO

9

GET TO HER BODY FIRST?

10

       A      OH, NO.  NO, THAT WAS NEVER EXPLAINED.

11

       Q      DID HE EVER EXPRESS TO YOU THAT HE KNEW --

12

WHETHER OR NOT HE KNEW IF HE COULD GET TO LAUREN'S BODY

13

FROM THE SACREDS COVE SIDE OF THE BEACH?

14

              DO YOU UNDERSTAND MY QUESTION?

15

       A      I THINK SO.

16

       Q      OKAY.  DID MR. BROWN EVER SAY TO YOU

17

SOMETHING ALONG THE LINES OF, "WELL, WHEN I WENT DOWN TO

18

SACREDS COVE, I DIDN'T KNOW I COULDN'T GET AROUND TO HER

19

BODY"?

20

       A      NO.

21

       Q      DID HE EVER SAY ANYTHING LIKE THAT?

22

       A      NEVER.

23

       Q      AND MR. BROWN, I BELIEVE YOU SAID,

24

INDICATED TO YOU THAT -- ORIGINALLY HE CLAIMED IT WAS NOT

25

HIS INTENTION TO GO TO THE BEACH, CORRECT?

26

       A      THAT'S CORRECT.

27

       Q      AND IT WAS NOT HIS INTENTION TO GO HIKING?

28

       A      NO.

197

1

       Q      DID MR. BROWN EVER EXPLAIN TO YOU WHY HE

2

WAS WEARING THE CLOTHING THAT HE WAS WEARING IF HE HAD

3

INTENDED TO TAKE HIS DAUGHTER BACK TO HIS APARTMENT?

4

       A      NO.

5

       Q      NOW, YOU SAID THAT YOU STARTED THE

6

INTERVIEW OF MR. BROWN AT ABOUT 12:20, 12:25 IN THE

7

MORNING ON NOVEMBER 9TH; IS THAT CORRECT?

8

       A      THAT'S CORRECT.

9

       Q      AND YOU SAID IT LASTED ABOUT FOUR HOURS; IS

10

THAT CORRECT?

11

       A      IT WAS ABOUT FOUR HOURS, YES.

12

       Q      LATER ON THAT DAY, WHICH WOULD BE

13

NOVEMBER 9TH STILL, DID YOU AND YOUR PARTNER GO TO THE

14

LOCATION AND ACTUALLY GO UP ONTO THE TOP OF INSPIRATION

15

POINT?

16

       A      YES.  NOW THAT IT WAS DAYLIGHT, WE DID

17

TRAVERSE OUT TO THE END OF THE POINT.

18

       Q      WAS THIS THE FIRST TIME THAT YOU HAD BEEN

19

UP THERE WITH REGARD TO THIS INVESTIGATION?

20

       A      WITH REGARD TO THIS INVESTIGATION?

21

       Q      CORRECT.

22

       A      THIS INVESTIGATION, YES.

23

       Q      DO YOU REMEMBER ABOUT WHAT TIME IT WAS WHEN

24

YOU AND YOUR PARTNER WENT OUT THERE?

25

       A      SOMETIME IN THE AFTERNOON.  1:00,

26

2:00 O'CLOCK IN THE AFTERNOON.

27

       Q      FROM THE TIME THAT THIS HAPPENED, FROM THE

28

TIME HOMICIDE WAS NOTIFIED UNTIL THE TIME YOU AND YOUR

198

1

PARTNER WENT OUT TO INSPIRATION POINT THE NEXT DAY, WAS

2

THAT SCENE SECURED?

3

       A      YES.

4

       Q      AND HOW WAS THAT SCENE SECURED?

5

       A      TWO UNIFORMED SHERIFF'S DEPUTIES, I BELIEVE

6

IT WAS A TWO-MAN CAR, WE MADE THEM SIT THERE ALL NIGHT

7

UNTIL WE RETURNED THE FOLLOWING MORNING -- OR DAY.

8

       Q      AND THE PURPOSE OF DOING THAT WAS WHAT?

9

       A      TO PRESERVE THE INTEGRITY OF THE SCENE, SO

10

NOBODY ELSE COULD GO OUT THERE.

11

       Q      NOW, WHEN YOU WENT OUT TO INSPIRATION

12

POINT, DID YOU WALK THROUGH THIS NECK AREA THAT YOU HAVE

13

DESCRIBED FOR US AND GO OUT ONTO THE WIDER PORTION OF

14

INSPIRATION POINT?

15

       A      YES, I DID.

16

       Q      AND DID YOU LOOK ALONG THE CLIFF?

17

       A      YES.

18

       Q      DID YOU FIND ANYTHING THAT SEEMED

19

SIGNIFICANT TO YOU IN ANY PART OF THAT AREA?

20

       A      YES.

21

       Q      TELL US WHAT THAT WAS.

22

       A      AT THE END OF THE CLIFF ON THE LEFT SIDE,

23

THAT AREA THAT SLOPES DOWN THAT I DESCRIBED YESTERDAY IN

24

THE PHOTOGRAPHS, MY PARTNER AND I NOTED WHAT APPEARED TO

25

BE SOME SHOE OR FOOT IMPRESSIONS IN THE DIRT.  AND THEY

26

LOOKED AS IF THEY WERE SIDEWAYS, NOT WALKING STRAIGHT

27

DOWN, BUT AS IF YOU WERE STEPPING SIDEWAYS.  AND THE AREA

28

AROUND IT WAS UNDISTURBED, BUT THEY WERE -- I WOULDN'T

199

1

SAY REAL DISTINCTIVE, BUT YOU COULD TELL THERE WERE

2

IMPRESSIONS MADE THAT SEEMED TO GO DOWNWARDS IN THAT

3

PARTICULAR AREA.

4

       Q      AND THOSE, WHAT APPEARED TO BE FOOTPRINTS,

5

WERE THOSE IN THE SAME AREA THAT MATCHED THE DESCRIPTION

6

OF WHERE MR. BROWN HAD SAID HE AND LAUREN HAD BEEN?

7

       A      YEAH.  NOT ONLY THAT, BUT IT ALSO WOULD

8

CORRELATE TO WHERE HER BODY WAS RECOVERED IN THE INLET ON

9

THAT SIDE.

10

       Q      DID YOU GO DOWN AND INSPECT THOSE

11

FOOTPRINTS AT THAT TIME?

12

       A      NO.

13

       Q      DID YOU, IN FACT, REQUEST MR. FALICON AND

14

SOME EMERGENCY SERVICES PEOPLE TO RESPOND AND ASSIST YOU

15

WITH THAT?

16

       A      YEAH.  TRYING TO DOCUMENT OR PRESERVE THOSE

17

WAS WAY TOO DANGEROUS WITHOUT PROPER SAFETY EQUIPMENT, SO

18

WE MADE ARRANGEMENTS THE FOLLOWING DAY TO HAVE OUR

19

EMERGENCY SERVICES DETAIL COME OUT, ALONG WITH A

20

PHOTOGRAPHER AND SOMEBODY WHO HAD THE ABILITY TO CAST.

21

REALLY NOBODY ELSE WANTED TO DO IT EXCEPT FOR DALE

22

FALICON.

23

       Q      AND THE NEXT DAY, WHICH WOULD HAVE BEEN

24

NOVEMBER 10TH OF 2000, DID, IN FACT, MR. FALICON GO OUT

25

THERE AND DOCUMENT THOSE IMPRESSIONS THAT YOU HAD SEEN

26

AND TAKE PLASTER CASTS OF MOST OF THEM?

27

       A      YES, HE DID.

28

       Q      AND YOU WERE THERE WHEN THAT HAPPENED?

200

1

       A      YES.

2

       Q      NOW, I THINK THAT YOU TESTIFIED

3

YESTERDAY -- LET ME BACK UP A LITTLE BIT.

4

              OTHER THAN THOSE IMPRESSIONS IN THAT AREA,

5

DID YOU SEE ANYTHING ELSE OUT THERE THAT APPEARED TO BE

6

FRESH IMPRESSIONS ALONG THE EDGE OF THE CLIFF -- ALONG

7

THE EDGE OF THE CLIFF AT ALL?

8

       A      NO.  THE REMAINDER OF THE DIRT WAS

9

UNDISTURBED IN THAT AREA.

10

       Q      NOW, I THINK YOU TOLD US YESTERDAY THAT

11

AFTER YOU GO THROUGH WHAT YOU HAVE REFERRED TO AS THE

12

NECK OF THE PATH AND OUT ONTO THE POINT THAT THE TRAIL

13

NATURALLY TAKES YOU OFF TO THE RIGHT; IS THAT CORRECT?

14

       A      YES, THAT'S CORRECT.

15

       Q      AND THAT WOULD BE THE SACREDS COVE/NUDE

16

BEACH SIDE OF INSPIRATION POINT, CORRECT?

17

       A      YES.

18

       Q      AND THEN YOU CAN ACTUALLY FOLLOW -- IF YOU

19

CONTINUE ON THE TRAIL, IT WILL GO ALONG THE FRONT EDGE OF

20

THE CLIFF, THE OCEAN EDGE, AND IT WILL TAKE YOU TO THE

21

LEFT SIDE OF THE POINT, WHICH IS THE ARCHERY RANGE SIDE,

22

CORRECT?

23

       A      YES, THAT'S CORRECT.

24

       Q      AND THAT'S THE AREA WHERE MR. BROWN

25

DESCRIBED FOR YOU, AND THAT'S THE AREA WHERE YOU FOUND

26

THE FOOTPRINTS, CORRECT?

27

       A      YES.

28

       Q      LET ME ASK YOU THIS:  IF ONE WERE TO GO, TO

201

1

TAKE THIS PATH TO THE RIGHT AS IT NORMALLY WOULD TAKE

2

YOU, AND GO OUT TO THE END OF INSPIRATION POINT ON THE

3

RIGHT SIDE, IF SOMEBODY IS STANDING IN THAT POSITION CAN

4

THEY BE SEEN BY PEOPLE ON THE BEACH BELOW AT SACREDS

5

COVE?

6

       A      YES, YOU WILL BE VERY VISIBLE FROM NOT ONLY

7

SACREDS COVE AND THE BEACH BELOW BUT ALSO PORTUGUESE

8

POINT JUST TO THE WEST OF IT.

9

       Q      SO IF YOU ARE STANDING ON THE POINT ON THE

10

RIGHT SIDE, YOU CAN BE SEEN FROM THE BEACH AND FROM

11

PORTUGUESE POINT?

12

       A      THAT'S CORRECT.  AND ALSO THE TRAILS THAT

13

WOULD LEAD DOWN BETWEEN THE TWO OF THEM.

14

       Q      NOW, WHAT ABOUT THE LEFT SIDE OF

15

INSPIRATION POINT WHERE MR. BROWN DESCRIBED HE WAS, WHERE

16

YOU FOUND THE FOOTPRINTS; IF SOMEONE WERE STANDING THERE,

17

CAN THEY BE SEEN FROM SACREDS COVE?

18

       A      NO.

19

       Q      CAN THEY BE SEEN FROM PORTUGUESE POINT?

20

       A      NO.

21

       Q      CAN THEY BE SEEN FROM THE BEACH BY THE

22

ARCHERY RANGE?

23

       A      NO.

24

       Q      WHERE WOULD SOMEONE HAVE TO BE STANDING IN

25

ORDER TO SEE AN INDIVIDUAL STANDING AT THE TOP OF

26

INSPIRATION POINT WHERE CAMERON BROWN STATED HE WAS?

27

       A      BECAUSE OF THE MAKEUP OF THE CLIFF AND THE

28

WAY IT SLOPES DOWN, THE ONLY TWO PLACES THAT YOU CAN

202

1

POSSIBLY BE SEEN IS IF YOU WERE STANDING ON THE ROCKS,

2

THE TIDE POOLS DIRECTLY BELOW, BUT ALMOST OUT TO WHERE IT

3

MEETS WITH THE OCEAN, OR IF YOU WERE DIRECTLY OFFSHORE ON

4

A BOAT OR A SHIP.

5

       Q      SO YOU CAN'T BE SEEN FROM THE SHORE AT ALL?

6

       A      NO.

7

       Q      JUST SO WE ARE CLEAR, THE AREA WHERE

8

CAMERON BROWN DESCRIBED LAUREN AS GOING OFF THE CLIFF, IS

9

THAT A SHEER DROP?  IN OTHER WORDS, IS THERE A LIP AND

10

THEN IT IS JUST A STRAIGHT DROP DOWN, OR IS THERE SOME

11

TYPE OF SLOPE TO THE CLIFF?

12

       A      NO, THERE'S A SLOPE.  IT IS NOT JUST A

13

STRAIGHT DROP.  IT IS A RATHER STEEP SLOPE, BUT IT'S A

14

SLOPE.

15

       Q      NOW, WHEN YOU WENT OUT TO INSPIRATION POINT

16

WITH MR. FALICON ON THE 10TH OF NOVEMBER, DID SOMEBODY

17

FROM THE EMERGENCY SERVICES BUREAU ALSO RAPPEL DOWN THE

18

CLIFF IN THE AREA WHERE MR. BROWN HAD CLAIMED LAUREN HAD

19

FALLEN?

20

       A      YES, DEPUTY TERRY ASCHERIN.

21

       Q      AND DID HE GIVE YOU OR RECOVER ANY EVIDENCE

22

THAT HE FOUND ALONG THE FACE OF THE CLIFF?

23

       A      NO.  HE TOLD US THAT HE WAS UNABLE TO SEE

24

ANYTHING SIGNIFICANT, IMPACTS OR BLOOD OR ANYTHING OF

25

THAT SORT.  NO EVIDENCE WAS RECOVERED BY HIM.

26

       Q      NOW, DID YOU ALSO WALK THE ROUTE THAT

27

CAMERON BROWN HAD DESCRIBED FOR YOU THAT HE CLAIMED HE

28

AND LAUREN HAD WALKED THE DAY THAT SHE DIED?

203

1

       A      YES.  I HAVE ACTUALLY WALKED IT SEVERAL

2

TIMES.

3

       Q      DID YOU WALK IT ON THE 10TH OF NOVEMBER?

4

       A      YES.  YES.

5

       Q      AND DID YOU ATTEMPT TO MEASURE DISTANCES

6

ALONG THAT ROUTE?

7

       A      YES, WE DID.

8

       Q      AND HOW DID YOU ATTEMPT TO MEASURE THE

9

DISTANCE?

10

       A      WALKING THE TRAILS, THE DISTANCE WAS

11

MEASURED WITH A ROLL-A-TAPE, WHAT THEY USE IN TRAFFIC

12

ACCIDENT INVESTIGATION.  IT ROLLS ON TWO WHEELS AND

13

CLICKS THE FEET AS YOU GO.

14

              WE DID OBTAIN A MEASUREMENT; HOWEVER,

15

BECAUSE OF THE STEEPNESS AND THE ROCKS AND THE TRAILS, I

16

DON'T KNOW THAT IT'S NECESSARILY PERFECTLY ACCURATE.  IF

17

ANYTHING, IT'S PROBABLY UNDER WHAT IT ACTUALLY IS BECAUSE

18

OF THE SKIPPING, BUT WE DID OBTAIN A MEASUREMENT OF

19

7,500 FEET.

20

       Q      THAT'S FROM THE PARKING LOT AT ABALONE

21

COVE, ALONG THE ROUTE THAT MR. BROWN DESCRIBED, UP TO THE

22

END OF INSPIRATION POINT?

23

       A      NO, IT'S UP TO THE POINT WHERE --

24

7,500 FEET UP TO THE POINT WHERE INSPIRATION POINT WOULD

25

INTERSECT WITH PALOS VERDES DRIVE SOUTH.  YOU WOULD HAVE

26

ANOTHER 212 FEET GOING OUT TOWARDS THE OCEAN OF

27

INSPIRATION POINT ITSELF.

28

       Q      YOU SAID 7,500 FEET?

204

1

       A      7,500 FEET.

2

       Q      IS THAT APPROXIMATELY A MILE AND A HALF?

3

       A      I BELIEVE SO.

4

       Q      DID YOU ALSO, JUST FOR SOME TYPE OF

5

REFERENCE POINT, MEASURE THE DISTANCE ALONG THE ROAD FROM

6

ABALONE COVE TO WHERE INSPIRATION POINT MEETS PALOS

7

VERDES DRIVE SOUTH?

8

       A      YEAH.  THAT WAS DONE BY CAR, WITH A VEHICLE

9

ODOMETER.

10

       Q      AND HOW FAR IS THAT?

11

       A      NINE-TENTHS OF A MILE FROM THE PARKING LOT

12

TO WHERE INSPIRATION POINT WOULD INTERSECT WITH PALOS

13

VERDES DRIVE SOUTH.

14

       Q      NOW, OBVIOUSLY YOU HIKED THE ROUTE WITH

15

YOUR PARTNER WHILE YOU WERE TAKING THE MEASUREMENTS,

16

CORRECT?

17

       A      YES.

18

       Q      IS THERE ANYTHING ABOUT TAKING THE

19

MEASUREMENTS THAT MAKES YOU WALK ANY SLOWER THAN A NORMAL

20

PACE?

21

       A      NO.  NO.

22

       Q      HOW LONG DID IT TAKE YOU AND YOUR PARTNER

23

TO MAKE THIS WALK THAT MR. BROWN CLAIMED HE AND LAUREN

24

HAD TAKEN?

25

       A      IT TOOK US 50 MINUTES, AND WE WERE WALKING

26

AT A MODERATE PACE.

27

       MS. PRIVER:  SORRY?

28

       Q      BY MR. HUM:  YOU SAY 50, FIVE OH?

205

1

       A      FIFTY, FIVE ZERO.

2

       Q      AND YOU SAID YOU HAVE BEEN OUT THERE A

3

NUMBER OF TIMES TO THE LOCATION, CORRECT?

4

       A      THAT'S CORRECT.

5

       Q      AND YOU HAVE HIKED THAT PATH A NUMBER OF

6

TIMES?

7

       A      YES.

8

       Q      BACK IN MARCH OF 2001 DID YOU GO OUT THERE

9

WITH THE CORONER, DR. CHINWAH, AND HIS BOSS, THE ACTUAL

10

CORONER OF LOS ANGELES COUNTY --

11

       A      DR. LAKSHMANAN, YES.

12

       Q      -- AND SOME OTHER INDIVIDUALS, A PEDIATRIC

13

CONSULTANT AND SOME OTHER SHERIFF'S PERSONNEL?

14

       A      YES.

15

       Q      AND DID YOU ALSO GO OUT THERE WITH ME AT

16

LEAST THREE DIFFERENT TIMES?

17

       A      YES.

18

       Q      IS ONE OF THOSE TIMES WITH DR. TOBY HAYES?

19

       A      YES.

20

       Q      A FEW MORE QUESTIONS, DETECTIVE.  ALSO AS

21

PART OF YOUR INVESTIGATION DID YOU SUBPOENA AND OBTAIN

22

FINANCIAL RECORDS ON CAMERON BROWN, INCLUDING BANK

23

RECORDS ON HIS BANK ACCOUNTS, PAYROLL RECORDS FROM

24

AMERICAN AIRLINES AND CREDIT RECORDS FROM THE CREDIT

25

REPORT AGENCIES?

26

       A      YES, I DID.

27

       Q      AND DID YOU PROVIDE THOSE TO ME AND TO A

28

FINANCIAL ANALYST FROM THE DISTRICT ATTORNEY'S OFFICE BY

206

1

THE NAME OF JANE NGO?

2

       A      YES, I DID.

3

       Q      NOW, DETECTIVE, YOU TOLD US THAT MR. BROWN

4

SAID HE MADE A 911 CALL FROM A CELLPHONE, CORRECT?

5

       A      THAT'S CORRECT.

6

       Q      AND YOU'RE FAMILIAR WITH HOW 911 CALLS FROM

7

CELLPHONES ARE ROUTED?

8

       A      YES.

9

       Q      HOW DOES THAT HAPPEN?

10

       A      911'S FROM CELLULAR TELEPHONES GO DIRECTLY

11

TO THE CALIFORNIA HIGHWAY PATROL COMMAND COMMUNICATION

12

CENTER.

13

       Q      AND FROM THERE ARE THEY ROUTED TO THE

14

APPROPRIATE AGENCIES?

15

       A      YES.

16

       Q      DID YOU, IN FACT, GO TO THE CALIFORNIA

17

HIGHWAY PATROL COMMUNICATION CENTER AND OBTAIN A COPY OF

18

THE 911 CELLULAR CALL THAT MR. BROWN MADE?

19

       A      YES, I DID.

20

       Q      AND HAVE YOU LISTENED TO THAT TAPE?

21

       A      SEVERAL TIMES.

22

       Q      DO YOU RECOGNIZE THE VOICE OF THE CALLER ON

23

IT AS MR. BROWN?

24

       A      YES, I DO.

25

       Q      NOW, THERE ARE ALSO SOME OTHER VOICES, THE

26

PEOPLE WHO ANSWER THE 911 CALL, AS WELL AS WHAT APPEAR TO

27

BE A COUPLE OF PEOPLE TALKING IN THE BACKGROUND; IS THAT

28

CORRECT?

207

1

       A      THAT'S CORRECT.

2

       Q      AND HAVE YOU ALSO REVIEWED A TRANSCRIPT

3

THAT WAS PREPARED OF THE 911 CALL?

4

       A      YES, I HAVE.

5

       Q      AND IS THAT SUBSTANTIALLY ACCURATE AS TO

6

WHAT THE 911 CALL SAYS?

7

       A      YES.

8

       MS. PRIVER:  DO YOU WANT TO PLAY THE TAPE?

9

       MR. HUM:  YES.

10

       MS. PRIVER:  DO YOU AGREE THAT THE COURT REPORTER

11

DOES NOT NEED TO TAKE DOWN THE TAPE SINCE THERE IS A

12

TRANSCRIPT IN EVIDENCE?

13

       MR. HUM:  YES.

14

       MS. PRIVER:  THE GRAND JURORS ARE ADMONISHED AND

15

ADVISED THAT THE TRANSCRIPT IS PROVIDED TO ASSIST YOU,

16

BUT THE TAPE IS ACTUALLY THE EVIDENCE.  SO YOU MUST GO BY

17

THE TAPE VERSUS THE TRANSCRIPT OF THE TAPE IF YOU FIND

18

PERSONALLY, WHEN LISTENING TO IT, THAT THERE IS A

19

DIFFERENCE.

20

       MR. HUM:  THANK YOU.

21

       Q      JUST SO WE ARE ALL CLEAR, THIS IS THE 911

22

CALL THAT MR. BROWN MAKES WHERE HE SAYS HE WAS CRYING

23

HYSTERICALLY AND COULDN'T STOP CRYING, CORRECT?

24

       A      COULD NOT STOP CRYING, YES, THAT'S CORRECT.

25

26

              (EXHIBIT 16 WAS PLAYED.)

27

28

       Q      BY MR. HUM:  DETECTIVE LESLIE, DO YOU

208

1

RECOGNIZE THE VOICE OF THE CALLER AS THAT OF CAMERON

2

BROWN?

3

       A      YES, THAT'S CAMERON BROWN.

4

       Q      THANK YOU, DETECTIVE.

5

       MR. HUM:  I HAVE NO FURTHER QUESTIONS.

6

       MS. PRIVER:  ANY QUESTIONS BY ANY MEMBER OF THE

7

GRAND JURY?

8

9

              (PAUSE IN THE PROCEEDINGS.)

10

11

       MS. PRIVER:  FOR THE RECORD, THE TAPE ITSELF IS

12

EXHIBIT 16 AND THE TRANSCRIPT IS EXHIBIT 17; IS THAT

13

CORRECT?

14

       MR. HUM:  YES.

15

16

              (PAUSE IN THE PROCEEDINGS.)

17

18

       MS. PRIVER:  THERE IS QUITE A FEW QUESTIONS.  WHY

19

DON'T WE TAKE OUR MORNING RECESS BEFORE WE ASK THE

20

QUESTIONS.

21

       MR. HUM:  WE CAN.

22

       MS. PRIVER:  DETECTIVE LESLIE, YOU HAVE PREVIOUSLY

23

BEEN ADMONISHED REGARDING THE CONFIDENTIALITY OF THE

24

GRAND JURY.

25

              DO YOU RECALL THAT ADMONITION?

26

       THE WITNESS:  YES, MA'AM; I DO.

27

       MS. PRIVER:  BECAUSE OF THE HOUR, WE ARE GOING TO

28

TAKE OUR MORNING RECESS.  THERE IS QUITE A FEW QUESTIONS.

209

1

PERHAPS WE CAN BE MORE EFFICIENT IF WE TAKE A BREAK AND

2

THEN ASK THEM.

3

              SO WE ARE GOING TO EXCUSE YOU AND WE WILL

4

CALL YOU BACK AFTER OUR BREAK.

5

       THE WITNESS:  YES, MA'AM.

6

       MS. PRIVER:  THANK YOU.

7

8

              (THE WITNESS EXITED THE GRAND JURY

9

              HEARING ROOM.)

10

11

       MS. PRIVER:  WOULD YOU RECESS THIS GRAND JURY FOR

12

10 MINUTES.

13

       THE FOREPERSON:  SO ORDERED.

14

       MS. PRIVER:  THE GRAND JURORS ARE ADMONISHED AND

15

ADVISED NOT TO DISCUSS THIS MATTER OR FORM ANY OPINION

16

UNTIL SUCH TIME AS IT IS GIVEN TO THEM FOR DELIBERATIONS.

17

18

              (RECESS.)

19

20

       MS. PRIVER:  MR. FOREPERSON, WOULD YOU CALL THIS

21

GRAND JURY HEARING BACK INTO SESSION, PLEASE.

22

       THE FOREPERSON:  SO ORDERED.

23

       MS. PRIVER:  LET THE RECORD REFLECT THAT THE SAME

24

NUMBER, AS WELL AS THE SAME GRAND JURORS, ARE NOW PRESENT

25

AS WERE PRESENT AT THIS MORNING'S ROLL CALL.

26

              ALSO PRESENT IS DEPUTY D.A. CRAIG HUM AND

27

MYSELF, THE LEGAL ADVISOR.

28

              YOU WISH TO RECALL DETECTIVE LESLIE?

210

1

       MR. HUM:  YES, PLEASE.

2

       MS. PRIVER:  DETECTIVE LESLIE, PLEASE.

3

4

              (PAUSE IN THE PROCEEDINGS.)

5

              (THE WITNESS ENTERED THE GRAND JURY

6

              HEARING ROOM.)

7

8

       MS. PRIVER:  HAVE A SEAT, PLEASE.

9

              STATE YOUR NAME FOR THE RECORD.

10

       THE WITNESS:  JEFFREY LESLIE.

11

       MS. PRIVER:  YOU ARE REMINDED YOU ARE STILL UNDER

12

OATH.

13

              DO YOU UNDERSTAND THAT?

14

       THE WITNESS:  YES, MA'AM.

15

       MS. PRIVER:  MR. HUM.

16

       MR. HUM:  THANK YOU.

17

       Q      DETECTIVE LESLIE, A FEW QUESTIONS.  YOU

18

INTERVIEWED A NUMBER OF WITNESSES WITH REGARD TO THIS

19

CASE, CORRECT?

20

       A      YES.

21

       Q      WERE YOU EVER ABLE TO LOCATE ANYONE THAT

22

ACTUALLY SAW LAUREN LEAVE THE CLIFF?

23

       A      NO.  NO.  ONLY PRIOR TO ARRIVING AT

24

INSPIRATION POINT.

25

       Q      YOU INDICATED THAT MR. BROWN TOLD YOU THAT

26

WHILE HE WAS DRIVING FROM LAUREN'S SCHOOL UP TO ABALONE

27

COVE HE MADE A NUMBER OF ATTEMPTS TO CALL HIS WIFE; IS

28

THAT CORRECT?

211

1

       A      THAT IS WHAT HE TOLD US, YES.

2

       Q      DID HE INDICATE WHETHER HE USED A CELLPHONE

3

OR HOW HE ATTEMPTED TO MAKE THOSE CALLS?

4

       A      HE DID NOT HAVE A CELLPHONE.  HE TOLD US

5

THAT HE STOPPED AT SEVERAL PAY PHONES ALONG THE WAY AND

6

ULTIMATELY MADE THE CALL ON A PAY PHONE LOCATED AT THE

7

ABALONE COVE PARKING LOT.

8

       Q      AND WHAT TIME WAS IT THAT MR. BROWN

9

INDICATED HE PICKED UP HIS DAUGHTER FROM THE SCHOOL?

10

       A      12:30 P.M.

11

       Q      AND YOU HEARD THE TIME ON THE C.H.P. TAPE,

12

THE TIME OF THE 911 CALL, RIGHT?

13

       A      YES.

14

       Q      AND WHAT TIME IS THAT?

15

       A      ABOUT 2:30 IN THE AFTERNOON.

16

       Q      WHEN YOU --

17

              IF THE TIME ON THE TAPE WERE TO INDICATE

18

1458 HOURS, WHAT TIME IS THAT IN LIKE REAL PEOPLE TIME?

19

       A      1458 WOULD BE TWO MINUTES TO 3:00 O'CLOCK.

20

       Q      SO 2:58?

21

       A      YES.

22

       Q      IN THE AFTERNOON?

23

       A      IN THE AFTERNOON.

24

       Q      WHEN YOU LOOKED AT MR. BROWN'S CLOTHING,

25

YOU INDICATED HIS BOOTS WERE WET?

26

       A      YES, THE BOOTS WERE WET.

27

       Q      WHAT ABOUT THE SOCKS?  DO YOU RECALL?

28

       A      I BELIEVE THE SOCKS WERE WET ALSO.  IT HAD

212

1

BEEN SEVERAL HOURS, SO THEY WEREN'T HOLDING AS MUCH WATER

2

AS THE LEATHER SHOES WERE, BUT THEY APPEARED TO BE WET.

3

       Q      WHEN YOU WENT --

4

              YOU INDICATED THAT AFTER YOU ARRIVED AT THE

5

ARCHERY RANGE ON NOVEMBER 8TH OF 2000 AT SOME POINT YOU

6

WALKED OUT ACTUALLY ONTO THE FLAT ROCKS AND TO THE INLET

7

WHERE LAUREN'S BODY HAD BEEN RECOVERED; IS THAT CORRECT?

8

       A      YES.

9

       Q      WAS IT GETTING DARK, OR WAS IT DARK WHEN

10

YOU GOT OUT THERE?

11

       A      IT WAS DARK WHEN WE ARRIVED.

12

       Q      BY THE TIME YOU ARRIVED HAD LAUREN'S BODY

13

ALREADY BEEN REMOVED TO THE ARCHERY RANGE TABLE?  IN

14

OTHER WORDS, WAS IT ALREADY ON THE ARCHERY RANGE TABLE

15

WHEN YOU ARRIVED?

16

       A      YES.

17

       Q      SO YOU NEVER SAW HER BODY IN THE WATER?

18

       A      NO.  NO.

19

       Q      DID YOU CHECK CAMERON BROWN'S CAR AT ANY

20

TIME?

21

       A      IT WAS DRIVEN TO THE LOMITA SHERIFF'S

22

STATION WITH HIS APPROVAL AND CONSENT TO LOOK THROUGH IT;

23

AND, YEAH, A CURSORY SEARCH WAS CONDUCTED.  HOWEVER,

24

NOTHING PERTAINING TO LAUREN'S DEATH WAS FOUND WITHIN THE

25

CAR.

26

       Q      OKAY.  SO YOU HAD A SHERIFF'S DEPUTY DRIVE

27

IT TO LOMITA STATION?

28

       A      THAT'S CORRECT.

213

1

       Q      AND MR. BROWN SAID GO AHEAD AND DO THAT?

2

       A      HE HAD ASKED US -- HE DIDN'T WANT TO LEAVE

3

IT PARKED IN THE PARKING FACILITY.  HE WANTED TO HAVE IT

4

ACCESSIBLE TO HIM AT LOMITA STATION, SO I ARRANGED FOR

5

ANOTHER DEPUTY SHERIFF TO DRIVE IT THERE FOR HIM.

6

       Q      DID YOU EVER HAVE OR REQUEST THAT THE BLOOD

7

EVIDENCE ON THE ROCKS BE ANALYZED TO SEE IF THE DNA

8

MATCHED LAUREN'S BLOOD?

9

       A      NO, THAT HAS NOT BEEN DONE.  IT WAS PRETTY

10

EVIDENT THAT THE BLOOD AND COAGULATED BLOOD/BRAIN MATTER

11

WAS ATTRIBUTED, DIRECTLY ATTRIBUTED, TO HER.  IT WAS

12

LOCATED ON THE FLAT ROCK WHERE HE SAID HE HAD PLACED HER

13

AND CONDUCTED C.P.R.

14

              THERE WAS NO EVIDENCE OF ANYBODY ELSE

15

BLEEDING OUT THERE, ESPECIALLY TO THAT EXTENT OF THE

16

COAGULATED BRAIN MATTER TYPE BLOOD, SO THAT WAS NOT DONE.

17

       Q      NOW, DURING HIGH TIDE DOES THE WATER

18

ACTUALLY COME UP ONTO THOSE ROCKS AND COVER THOSE ROCKS?

19

       A      A PORTION OF THEM, YES.

20

       Q      YOU TRIED TO -- HAVE YOU TRIED TO GET OUT

21

TO THE ROCKS DURING HIGH TIDE?

22

       A      YES, I HAVE.

23

       Q      AND YOU COULDN'T MAKE IT AND YOU GOT AWFUL

24

WET?

25

       A      THAT'S CORRECT.

26

       Q      HOW ABOUT THE BLOOD ON MR. BROWN'S SHIRT

27

AND SOCKS; DID YOU HAVE THAT ANALYZED, OR DID YOU FEEL

28

THERE WAS ANY NECESSITY FOR THAT?

214

1

       A      IT HAS NOT.  IT'S BEEN -- IT'S BEEN SEIZED.

2

IT'S BEEN FROZEN.  IT IS THERE FOR ANY FUTURE ANALYSIS.

3

HOWEVER, I DON'T KNOW WHAT IT WOULD TELL US OTHER THAN

4

IT'S HER BLOOD.

5

       Q      DID YOU SEE ANY INDICATION THAT MR. BROWN

6

WAS BLEEDING AT ALL?

7

       A      NO.  AND, AGAIN, I SPECIFICALLY LOOKED FOR

8

THAT BECAUSE I EXPECTED THERE TO BE SCRAPES, ABRASIONS,

9

CUTS, BRUISES; AND THERE WAS NOTHING INDICATING THAT HE

10

WAS BLEEDING WHATSOEVER.

11

       Q      NOW, AT SOME POINT YOU SERVED A SEARCH

12

WARRANT ON MR. BROWN'S RESIDENCE, CORRECT?

13

       A      THAT'S CORRECT.

14

       Q      DID YOU SEE ANY INDICATION THAT MR. BROWN

15

HAD TAKEN PHOTOGRAPHS OF LAUREN PREVIOUSLY?  AND, IF SO,

16

A LOT, A FEW?

17

       A      THERE WERE VERY FEW PHOTOGRAPHS OF LAUREN.

18

MR. BROWN HAD RECEIVED SOME FROM LAUREN'S MOTHER; THEY

19

WERE NOT TAKEN BY HIM.

20

              THERE WERE SOME PHOTOGRAPHS TAKEN OF LAUREN

21

IN AN ATTEMPT TO DEPICT INJURIES TO HER THAT HE HAD

22

ATTRIBUTED TO CLAIMS THAT HER MOTHER, SARAH MARER, WAS

23

ABUSING HER.  THOSE WERE THE ONLY PHOTOGRAPHS THAT I SAW

24

THAT WERE ACTUALLY TAKEN BY CAMERON BROWN.

25

              THE OTHERS WERE PROVIDED TO HIM, AND THEY

26

WERE VERY LIMITED.

27

       Q      AND SOME OF THE PHOTOS, COULD YOU TELL THAT

28

THEY HAD BEEN PROVIDED BECAUSE THEY APPEARED TO HAVE BEEN

215

1

PHOTOS OF LAUREN AND SARAH AND SARAH HAD ACTUALLY BEEN

2

CUT OFF THE PHOTOGRAPHS SO IT WAS ONLY LAUREN?

3

       A      THAT'S CORRECT.

4

       Q      DID YOU FIND ANY OTHER PICTURES AT

5

MR. BROWN'S RESIDENCE OR ANYWHERE ELSE THAT DEPICTED HER

6

PLAYING ON THE BEACH OR ANYTHING LIKE THAT THAT YOU CAN

7

RECALL?

8

       A      THERE WERE NO PHOTOGRAPHS OF THAT NATURE.

9

       Q      BASED ON THE CASTS THAT WERE LIFTED BY

10

MR. FALICON, WERE YOU EVER ABLE TO COMPARE THOSE CASTS TO

11

ANYONE'S SHOES?

12

       A      NO.

13

       Q      NOW, THE NIGHT THIS HAPPENED, DID YOU TAKE

14

MR. BROWN'S BOOTS?

15

       A      NO.

16

       Q      IN RETROSPECT, SHOULD YOU HAVE TAKEN

17

MR. BROWN'S BOOTS?

18

       A      YES.

19

       Q      AT SOME POINT DID YOU ATTEMPT TO GET

20

MR. BROWN'S BOOTS FROM HIM?

21

       A      YES, WE DID.

22

       Q      AND ABOUT HOW MUCH LATER WAS THAT?

23

       A      I THINK IT WAS A COUPLE OF DAYS.

24

       Q      AND WHAT DID MR. BROWN TELL YOU?

25

       A      HE SAID --

26

              MAYBE IT WAS A WEEK OR SO.

27

              HE HAD INDICATED TO US THAT HE HAD THROWN

28

THE SHOES AWAY THE DAY OR SO AFTER THE INCIDENT.

216

1

       Q      WHEN YOU WERE OUT THERE LOOKING FOR

2

THESE -- FOR ANY SHOE IMPRESSIONS, DID YOU SEE ANY SHOE

3

IMPRESSIONS THAT WOULD INDICATE THAT A CHILD WAS RUNNING

4

AROUND OR PLAYING IN THAT SAME AREA?

5

       A      ABSOLUTELY NOT.

6

       Q      NOW, YOU HAVE LOOKED AT THE CONTOURS OF THE

7

CLIFF FROM ABOVE AND BELOW, CORRECT?

8

       A      YES.

9

       Q      WE HAVE ALSO HAD AN EXPERT CONDUCT A

10

DETAILED ANALYSIS OF THE SHAPES OF THE CLIFF AND THE

11

VARIOUS PORTIONS OF IT, AND THAT PERSON WILL BE

12

TESTIFYING LATER, CORRECT?

13

       A      THAT'S CORRECT.

14

       Q      DID MR. BROWN INDICATE TO YOU WHETHER OR

15

NOT HE WAS FAMILIAR WITH THIS PARTICULAR AREA?

16

       A      HE SAID HE WAS FAMILIAR WITH THE AREA;

17

HOWEVER, HE HAD NEVER BEEN TO THAT PARTICULAR POINT

18

BEFORE, NOR HAD HE BEEN THERE WITH THE CHILD.

19

              SO MY INTERPRETATION OF THAT WAS HE WAS

20

FAMILIAR WITH MORE OF THE ROAD AND GENERALLY WHAT WAS IN

21

THE AREA; HOWEVER, I GOT THE IMPRESSION HE HAD NOT

22

TRAVERSED IT AND KNEW SPECIFICS.  MORE GENERALITIES.

23

       Q      YOU DID HEAR ON THE 911 TAPE THAT HE

24

INDICATED HE WAS NEAR THE ARCHERY RANGE, CORRECT?

25

       A      YES.

26

       Q      WAS THERE --

27

              DID HE EVER TELL YOU THAT HE HAD BEEN TO

28

THAT ARCHERY RANGE OR HOW HE KNEW THAT THERE WAS AN

217

1

ARCHERY RANGE THERE?

2

       A      NO.  IN FACT, IT IS VERY, VERY ODD BECAUSE

3

IF YOU HAD NOT BEEN THERE, YOU WOULD NOT HAVE KNOWN.  WE

4

HAD ACTUALLY SPOKEN TO A WITNESS WHO SAID HE HIKES THAT

5

AREA EVERY DAY, HE HAD GROWN UP THERE FOR THE LAST 30

6

YEARS, AND HE DID NOT KNOW THAT THE ARCHERY RANGE WAS

7

THERE.

8

       MS. PRIVER:  THAT IS NOT BEING OFFERED FOR THE

9

TRUTH OF THE MATTER ASSERTED, BUT TO EXPLAIN THE

10

OFFICER'S FEELING THAT IT WAS ODD.

11

       Q      BY MR. HUM:  AND CAN YOU SEE, FOR EXAMPLE,

12

THE ARCHERY RANGE FROM THE ROAD?

13

       A      NO, YOU CAN'T.

14

       Q      ARE THERE SIGNS THAT SAY "ARCHERY RANGE

15

THIS WAY"?

16

       A      THERE ARE NOT.  AS I RECALL, THERE MAY BE

17

ONE VERY SMALL SIGN AS YOU ACTUALLY ENTER THE GATE, BUT

18

IT WOULD NOT BE SEEN FROM THE ROAD.  YOU WOULD NEED TO BE

19

GOING ONTO THE DIRT AND UP TO WHERE IT IS BLOCKED OFF BY

20

A GATE TO ACTUALLY SEE.  AND I AM NOT EVEN POSITIVE OF

21

THAT.  THERE IS SOMETHING THAT SEEMS FAMILIAR, A VERY,

22

VERY OLD SIGN THAT IS VERY HARD TO READ, BUT I AM NOT

23

POSITIVE.

24

       Q      DID MR. BROWN INDICATE TO YOU WHETHER OR

25

NOT HE BELIEVED HIS DAUGHTER WAS DEAD WHEN HE WAS

26

ATTEMPTING C.P.R. ON THE ROCKS?

27

       A      HE DIDN'T SAY ONE WAY OR THE OTHER, AS I

28

RECALL.

218

1

       Q      DURING THE INTERVIEW WITH MR. BROWN THAT

2

NIGHT, YOU SAID IT LASTED ABOUT FOUR HOURS AND YOU

3

SAID -- YOU DESCRIBED HIS DEMEANOR.  DID HE EVER APPEAR

4

TO GET FRUSTRATED OR ANGRY WITH YOU DURING THIS

5

INTERVIEW?

6

       A      NO.  AND THAT'S ACTUALLY WHAT I WAS LOOKING

7

FOR.  THAT WAS THE OTHER ODDITY.

8

              AND, AGAIN, IT'S HARD TO SAY WHAT'S NORMAL,

9

WHAT'S ABNORMAL; BUT YOU CAN CERTAINLY EXPECT CERTAIN

10

THINGS AND CERTAIN REACTIONS FROM PEOPLE WHO ARE

11

INNOCENT.

12

              WHEN SOMEBODY IS CONFRONTING YOU AND

13

TELLING YOU, "YOU DID THIS, YOU DID THIS, YOU DID THIS,"

14

AT A CERTAIN POINT IN TIME PEOPLE ARE GOING TO BECOME

15

ANGRY, ANGERED, AND FIRE BACK AND BECOME EMOTIONAL AND

16

SAY, "NO, I DIDN'T DO THIS.  YOU ARE NOT UNDERSTANDING."

17

AND THERE WAS NEVER ANY OF THAT.

18

              IT WAS, "NO.  NO, I TOLD YOU WHAT HAPPENED.

19

YOU WROTE IT DOWN."

20

              THERE WAS NO EMOTION WHATSOEVER.

21

       MS. PRIVER:  THAT IS BASED ON YOUR OWN EXPERIENCE

22

AND YOUR TRAINING IN INTERVIEW TECHNIQUES?

23

       THE WITNESS:  BASED ON WHAT I HAVE LEARNED THROUGH

24

INTERVIEWS, INTERROGATIONS, BOTH AT SCHOOLS AND IN

25

CONDUCTING INTERVIEWS OVER THE LAST 18 YEARS, YES.

26

       MR. HUM:  THANK YOU.

27

       MS. PRIVER:  ANY FOLLOW-UP QUESTIONS?

28

219

1

              (SHORT PAUSE.)

2

3

       MS. PRIVER:  THERE AREN'T ANY ADDITIONAL

4

QUESTIONS.

5

              THANK YOU, DETECTIVE.

6

              YOU ARE ONCE AGAIN REMINDED OF THE

7

ADMONITION REGARDING THE CONFIDENTIALITY OF THE GRAND

8

JURY, AND YOU ARE EXCUSED.

9

       THE WITNESS:  YES, MA'AM.  THANK YOU.

10

11

              (THE WITNESS EXITED THE GRAND JURY

12

              HEARING ROOM.)

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28